Jump to content


Where Is It OK to Start Walk-Ons?


Recommended Posts

Great question from a caller on S&B just now.

 

Where is it "OK" to have a walk-on as a starter - according to fans?  His example: it's OK to have a walk-on starting at WR - Brandon Reilly for example - but not "OK" to have a walk-on starting at quarterback.

 

What does HuskerBoard think?

Link to comment

I'm pretty much ok with walk-ons being starters at your specialist spots (K/P/LS), and occasionally OL/DL/LB.  You should never have a walk on at WR/QB/RB/Secondary unless something truly crazy happens/you absolutely whiff at recruiting.

 

OL/DL can be tricky to predict and sometimes you get a guy that just makes huge strides and pushes his way into earning some playing time.  For whatever reason Nebraska seems to get a pretty good LB out of a walk on every few years or so.  Weber being the latest example.

Edited by Xmas32
  • Plus1 1
Link to comment

I don't think that's quite the angle he was going for.

 

It's more if a walk-on works his way into a starting job at OL or WR, a lot of fans will embrace that as showing the value of the walk-on tradition and rewarding the guy for his hard work.  But if a walk-on were to start at QB or RB, it would be viewed as the guys we recruited at those positions being failures and a sign that our recruiting wasn't getting the job done.

 

Edit: This was in reply to @Cdog923 and @BigRedBuster

Edited by Mavric
  • Plus1 7
Link to comment

2 minutes ago, Mavric said:

I don't think that's quite the angle he was going for.

 

It's more if a walk-on works his way into a starting job at OL or WR, a lot of fans will embrace that as showing the value of the walk-on tradition and rewarding the guy for his hard work.  But if a walk-on were to start at QB or RB, it would be viewed as the guys we recruited at those positions being failures and a sign that our recruiting wasn't getting the job done.

 

Ahh, I get it. 

 

That is absolutely how it's going to be perceived if Bunch is named starter, or if Wyatt Mazour was named starter at RB. Those are the "money" positions in recruiting that get the most attention in recruiting. It could be that way at any position that a team has recruiting highly at for a number of years, though. What if a guy like Owen Pappoe comes to Nebraska, but gets beat out by a Chris Weber. Would we be ok with the look of that? 

 

 

Edited by Cdog923
Link to comment
Just now, Mavric said:

I don't think that's quite the angle he was going for.

 

It's more if a walk-on works his way into a starting job at OL or WR, a lot of fans will embrace that as showing the value of the walk-on tradition and rewarding the guy for his hard work.  But if a walk-on were to start at QB or RB, it would be viewed as the guys we recruited at those positions being failures and a sign that our recruiting wasn't getting the job done.

 

I tried to make a similar point.  It is concerning if recruiting targets at key skill positions like QB and RB aren't able to beat out a walk-on guy at those spots.  Too me, it shows failure in recruiting rather than a walk-on having a ton of overlooked talent.

Link to comment
2 minutes ago, Mavric said:

I don't think that's quite the angle he was going for.

 

It's more if a walk-on works his way into a starting job at OL or WR, a lot of fans will embrace that as showing the value of the walk-on tradition and rewarding the guy for his hard work.  But if a walk-on were to start at QB or RB, it would be viewed as the guys we recruited at those positions being failures and a sign that our recruiting wasn't getting the job done.

 

Edit: This was in reply to @Cdog923 and @BigRedBuster

 

I understood what he was getting at.

 

My point is, I don't agree with fans with that attitude.

  • Plus1 1
Link to comment

Walk-ons typically don't have scholarships for a reason, typically because their measurables aren't as good coming out of high school. At some positions, hard work and coaching can overcome those deficiencies.

A walk-on OL can get to be a starter by living in the weight room and having the right mentality.

A walk-on WR can do the same, but he's likely going to be limited in some area (height, speed, elusiveness) so he has to develop a niche. If he does, he can still help the offense because we need a variety of receivers.

A walk-on QB has the hardest battle because not only is he dealing with the same physical limitations that many walk-ons have, he is also competing for just 1 spot. If he ends up starting that usually means he overcame many of those limitations, the services missed him, or the scholarship guys were busts/hurt.

  • Plus1 1
Link to comment

Joe Ganz was a scholarship player from Illinois.  However, he was very low rated at .7889 out of HS.  If he were from Nebraska, I have no doubt he would have been asked to walk-on.....and, if he was the typical Nebraska kid, he would have done so.

 

There were a lot of Husker fans that were claiming he would never see the field as a player.

 

So.....if he were actually from Nebraska, rated the same and asked to walk-on, should he have never started.....just because he was a walk-on?

Link to comment

At one time or another we've started a walk-on, or former walk-on, at every position on the field.  Even QB.  (The legend of The Turmanator!)

 

The  most common positions for walk-on starters are probably fullback, punter and kicker.  Lately though we don't play a fullback much.  That, and we give scholies to punters and kickers.  So I'm not sure what the answer is.   

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...