Are you going to stand there and say our QB play is acceptable the last 2 years? If it was to Frosts standards he would open the playbook like UCF.
Are you going to stand there and say that all of our offensive troubles are 100% on the quarterbacks and that they are the ones holding everything else back?
He wouldn’t have to bring in McCaffrey to run fast paced drives.
He doesn't. That's what people want to see. We had to go fast when he got into the Northwestern game because we were behind late - everyone goes fast in that situation. We didn't go any faster against Penn State. McCaffrey got two series in the first half against Iowa that really weren't any different. Then he got three plays in the second half specifically designed for him to run the ball.
There wouldn’t be a QB competition halfway through the season between a junior and a project freshman QB. It’s not good enough on the field.
I don't think there's really a competition. I think they see the potential in Luke so they want to keep developing him. But Martinez has always been the guy. They kind of got backed into a corner after we lost to Northwestern and McCaffrey looked like he moved the ball better late in that game (even though we didn't score). So after a bad showing from Martinez and two losses they felt like they had to try something different so Luke go the start against Penn State. He really didn't play all that great but we won so you almost have to run him back out there again. After a dismal showing against Illinois Martinez finally got back in there and - barring injury - is there to stay.
I don’t know anyone who thinks Martinez has gotten better the last few years- do you?
Well, Pro Football Focus does. His grade for this year is higher than his grade for 2018. But who would want an unbiased, third-party option that objectively grades each play all season.