The point was they have let me down every year under Frost, by 3-5 wins of where I thought they should be. We thought the O line looked promising last year, Omar Manning coming in, the Blackshirts seem much improved in a weird year with a weak back end of the schedule, yada yada yada. Where did that end up? My thought is that they simply have to exceed expectations at prediction of 3-9 or I'll just mail in my fandom after that point.
I can see that 5-7 seems fairly likely:
Illinois - W or L
Buffalo - W
OU - L
MSU - W or L
NW - W or L
Michigan- L
Minnesota - W or L
Purdue - W or L
OSU - L
SELA - W
Wisconsin - L
Iowa - L
However, what year have they beaten anyone they weren’t supposed to? None besides 2016 MSU under Riley, hasn't happened under Frost once. How many years do they lose to someone they shouldn't? Every year. Are you ready to say they'll beat Wisconsin or Iowa? Me neither. I see 2 guaranteed wins on that schedule. 3-9, 4-8 isn't far off when you look at this objectively as you say, closer than 7-5 or 8-4 when I go game by game. I really get what you're saying but what on earth gives you reason to trust this team at all?
I want them to succeed as bad as anyone but they have flat out underperformed for a decade now and it's silly to expect otherwise until they prove it with wins. I expect as much when the preseason stuff comes out, no one will be trusting this team much wins and losses wise, it's just a fact right now.