Alright Knapp, you keep harping on this all the time about him being on equal footing passing-wise, so I'm just going to pose this question to you.... If you are down in the 4th quarter and have to drive 80 yds with just a few minutes left(a passing situation) would you rather have Taylor or Scott Frost? Taylor or Tommie? Taylor or Crouch? Taylor or Ganz? Because I'd take all the others every time. And yes, I'd take Crouch as a sophomore over Taylor. I realize that none of these guys are great passers, and don't think for a second that we don't all understand that. But, his decision making is terrible and he puts the ball on the ground more than all those others combined. I love Nebraska football, but to be honest it's frustrating that I'm going to be stuck watching our offense with him leading it for 2 more years. Our chances of getting to a National Title game are slim as is because I don't think we have near the players on D that are common in the SEC particularly in the front 4. Without consistent play at QB and someone with the ability to hit our guys in stride and distribute the ball effectively to all the talent we've got, we won't sniff the top 5 in the next 3 years. Up to this point the other teams have stopped themselves more than we've stopped them, and we've been extremely fortunate that we haven't turned over the ball much more. I don't think that Wisky is a great team and I think the Big 10 as a whole is weak, but we aren't a good football team right now.
Of the guys you mentioned, the only one with markedly better stats passing is Ganz. Ganz was a pocket passer who SUCKED running the ball. Ganz ran a very different offense and was a VERY different kind of QB.
In your scenario, where the team is down late in the game and has to drive 80 yards to win, only one QB you've mentioned has done it successfully, and he needed a miracle bounce off Shevin Wiggins' foot to get it done. Crouch didn't ever, one time, bring us back to win a game through the air like that. Neither did Frazier, neither did Berringer, neither did any of our glitterati at QB in the glory days. Only Frost, and again, only via a miracle.
Absolutely Martinez has flaws. So did all those other guys. But the most glaring difference is that Martinez isn't playing on a team even remotely comparable to the teams Frost, Crouch or Frazier played on. This O Line is light-years behind those lines. It is such a tremendously unfair comparison.
You can be frustrated with Martinez all you want. Lord knows he gives you plenty of reasons for frustration, between poor decisions passing, fumbles, etc. But you're not going to see Martinez playing for a national championship not because
Martinez can't get it done, but because our whole team can't get it done - not the way they're playing now.