1) He shouldn't have changed the way it's been done. That's pretty obvious.
2) If the defense isn't ready to wear Blackshirts after Fall Camp, whose fault is that?
1) I'm fine with this tradition evolving. I don't think it's as much of a distraction than any other weird or redundant question any reporter asks.
2) I understand what you are saying, however how do you decipher whether or not they are ready to play at that level yet??? You can be the best practice player in the world but it means nothing if you don't do it on Saturdays.
2) I hear this saying a lot - "You can be the best practice player in the world but it means nothing if you don't do it on Saturdays."
Is there any actual example of a guy being like this? I'm trying really hard to think of a defender over the last 5 years where coaches raved about the way he practiced, started him, and then it didn't show on gameday.
Besides, everything that happens on gameday is earned in practice. Everyone here knows that the 90's are never going to happen again, but that doesn't mean there's less truth to the idea that in those days, the practices were tougher than the games. That's why those defenses looked so bloodthirsty on Saturdays - they were like that every single day. If the defense hasn't earned their Blackshirts by the way that they're practicing, then they're not going to suddenly turn into Blackshirts on gameday. They've got to learn to treat every day like gameday if they're going to live up to the tradition.
Marcus Mendoza, Zack Lee, and Sam Keller are good examples.
None of those guys were Blackshirts. Sam Keller lost his starting job to an injury. Zac Lee lost his job in practice, not on gameday, and I don't think Marcus Mendoza ever earned a starting position.