Jump to content


TE James Carnie


Mavric

To which school will Carnie commit?  

38 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts


19 hours ago, Decked said:

If we don’t offer this guy and we let him go to Iowa...somebody needs to get canned. This dude is gonna torch us if we don’t. 

 

He may or may not get a NU offer - he then may go to NU or Iowa.  But the above seems a little over the top. It seems like the idea is to offer anybody that is leaning towards a BIG school that may have the ability to torch us.  How many scholarships do we get each year?

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment

57 minutes ago, GBRFAN said:

 

He may or may not get a NU offer - he then may go to NU or Iowa.  But the above seems a little over the top. It seems like the idea is to offer anybody that is leaning towards a BIG school that may have the ability to torch us.  How many scholarships do we get each year?

Letting a homegrown kid go to Iowa that wants to be N is different than a kid going to Iowa from Illinois who kills us every year. Especially when he is better than 1 of your already committed TEs. 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Decked said:

Letting a homegrown kid go to Iowa that wants to be N is different than a kid going to Iowa from Illinois who kills us every year. Especially when he is better than 1 of your already committed TEs. 

Sure, but we have three “homegrown” kids at the TE position. Essentially you’re saying that the talent evaluation of the coaching staff is poor if they take Rollins over Carnie and that they need to be replaced because of that lack of talent judgement. But isn’t that always the case that the coaches job security is based on good talent evaluation? Can you imagine if we had the in state talent of Texas of Florida. We’d have to let really good in state kids go

to rival schools every year. 

  • Fire 1
Link to comment
21 minutes ago, default_28 said:

Sure, but we have three “homegrown” kids at the TE position. Essentially you’re saying that the talent evaluation of the coaching staff is poor if they take Rollins over Carnie and that they need to be replaced because of that lack of talent judgement. But isn’t that always the case that the coaches job security is based on good talent evaluation? Can you imagine if we had the in state talent of Texas of Florida. We’d have to let really good in state kids go

to rival schools every year. 

Except that we don’t have that luxury. No need for made up scenarios. I would also take Iowa’s judgement any day of the week on a TE prospect over Beckton and Frost. If he was that good then Iowa would have offered Rollins. Luckily Fidone is so good that it could negate whatever loss Carnie may potentially bring. Our TE room has been bottom of the barrel in the Big ten. Hoping for Vokolek to shine because Stoll, Allen, and Rafdal ain’t cutting it so far. 

  • Plus1 2
Link to comment
4 hours ago, Decked said:

Letting a homegrown kid go to Iowa that wants to be N is different than a kid going to Iowa from Illinois who kills us every year. Especially when he is better than 1 of your already committed TEs. 

 

Everything you just stated is true - but very different then the earlier post.

Link to comment

2 hours ago, Decked said:

Except that we don’t have that luxury. No need for made up scenarios. I would also take Iowa’s judgement any day of the week on a TE prospect over Beckton and Frost. If he was that good then Iowa would have offered Rollins. Luckily Fidone is so good that it could negate whatever loss Carnie may potentially bring. Our TE room has been bottom of the barrel in the Big ten. Hoping for Vokolek to shine because Stoll, Allen, and Rafdal ain’t cutting it so far. 

 

Lots of good in this post. 0nly thing that may be a factor is that rollins could have not shown interest towards Iowa hence no offer - don't know if its the case and don't know where iowa would have put them on their board if true.

Link to comment
5 hours ago, Decked said:

Letting a homegrown kid go to Iowa that wants to be N is different than a kid going to Iowa from Illinois who kills us every year. Especially when he is better than 1 of your already committed TEs. 

Carnie would run through every wall between Norris and Memorial Stadium to wear the N. 

 

Rollins would be on the basketball court if given the choice. 

  • Plus1 1
  • Fire 1
Link to comment
6 hours ago, GBRFAN said:

 

What will you lose?  you got a bet with teachercd?

Teach is probably going through withdrawals from no gamedays in Lnk.

1 hour ago, GBRFAN said:

 

Lots of good in this post. 0nly thing that may be a factor is that rollins could have not shown interest towards Iowa hence no offer - don't know if its the case and don't know where iowa would have put them on their board if true.

Rollins was quoted previously saying Iowa was an offer he really wants. 

Link to comment
  • Mavric changed the title to TE James Carnie

He talked to Beckton yesterday as they do most Sundays.  Beckton told him he will be a topic of discussion when Beckton meets with Frost this week to decide what they want to do.  He said numbers are tight - especially with two TEs already committed - but we aslo don't have a lot of TEs on the roster.  Carnie seems to be favoring playing TE so bringing him in with the chance to play defense doesn't seem as appealing.

 

With Iowa offering and sounding like Kansas State may be right on their heels, we probably need to go for it or the ship might sail.

  • Plus1 5
Link to comment
  • Mavric changed the title to TE James Carnie
  • Mavric pinned this topic

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...