Nebraska wins and it's not really that close.
Alabama's defensive stats were very good that year but they played a pretty easy schedule and didn't do anything completely crazy.
outside of the bowl game they played 3 ranked teams. Tennesse, Missisippi State and Florida.
Tennesse had 3 losses on the year, Florida had 4 losses on the year and Missisippi State had 5.
Against two of those ranked teams, Missisppi State and Florida - Alabama gave up 21 points.
That same year 6 other teams held Missippi State to less than 21 points. Including a 5-6 South Carolina team that held them to 6 points and 2-10 LSU (the worst team in the conference that year by a wide margin) held Missisppi State to just 3 points. HALF the schedule held Missippi State to fewer points that supposedly powerhouse Alabama.
That same year 3 other teams held Florida to less than 21 points and Florida only scored more than 28 points 4 times that entire season and that was to the 4 worst teams on the schedule. (2 win LSU, 4 win Kentucky, 4 win Vanderbilt and 5 win Louisville)
So yes Alabama had great statistics but their schedule was very favorable and they really didn't hold anyone of note to any defensive lows other teams weren't also doing.
- It also helps that the highest ranked team in the SEC that year besides Alabama was #8 ranked 10-2 Georgia and Alabama didn't play them that year.
Alabama played a Miami team in the bowl game that beat #3 Florida State 19-16 and #7 Penn State 17-14. The rest of Miami's schedule that year was Boise State-like.
Nebraska destroyed a Florida team that had beaten 5 ranked teams (soundly) and had people considering them to be among the greatest teams of all time before the game.
Statistics of note. - Alabama beat the 3 ranked teams on the regular season schedule by an average of 7.6 Points.
- Nebraska beat the 3 ranked teams on the regular season schedule by an average of 28.3 Points,
Miami went into the bowl game with Alabama as a team averaging 30.8PPG on offense and allowing 13.4PPG on defense. Alabama surpassed both averages easily BUT while they did score 10 more points than any other team on Miami's schedule the Defense did NOT hold Miami to their season low on offense. Heck 5-6 Arizona held miami to just 8 points in an 8-7 loss that year.
Florida went into the bowl game with Nebraska as a team averaging 42,9PPG on offense and allowing 20.2PPG on defense. Nebraska held them to their season low offensively and nearly doubled the next highest point total Florida gave up on the season.
Miami's D was great in 1992, but it was also overrated.
If Jackie Sherill's 7-5 Missisppi State team with dual threat QB Greg Plump could put up 21 points on that Alabama team.. I think 1995 Nebraska could manage to put up 42 and considering Alabama only averaged 28ppg on the year they probably don't even make their average.
I'd go 42-17 Nebraska.