ToddB10000
Three-Star Recruit
How can you argue that a current coach's ineptness in any way proves whether or not a previous coach was worthwile?
I don't have strong feelings about Solich one way or the other, but BC's struggles are not evidence of Solich's value...
How else to you "value" anything than by comparison? How do you "value" a quarterback? Rank Sam Keller without comparing him to Zac Taylor. Sam has what, 11 TD passes and 10 INTs? Ok - rank the value of that without looking at anything else. You can't. You have to compare the two in order to find value. How about Joe Daily vs Jamal Lord? Jamal vs Eric Crouch?
BC's struggles are absolute evidence of Solich's value - they both held the same job at the same place. Solich did better when you look at the one thing that matters - Wins. Now compare Solich to Osborne. Osborne wins.