BCS to impliment Instant Replay

Associated Press

June 6th, 2005

Bowl Championship Series officials want instant replay used in all bowl games starting this season, and are confident it can be done.

"The commissioners are looking at the possibility of having video replay, at a minimum, available for the national title game and optimistically for all bowl games," BCS spokesman Bob Burda said Wednesday.

The Rose Bowl will host the national title game Jan. 4.

The Big Ten became the first conference to use video review of football game officials' calls last season, with an official in the press box determining if a play would be reviewed and overturning the call if replay showed conclusively it was wrong.

The NCAA gave all Division I-A conferences to opportunity to experiment with replay this season, and nine of 11 have adopted the Big Ten's system or some variation.

The Western Athletic Conference and Sun Belt will not use replay this season.

"The use of replay for the majority of leagues is predicated on games being televised," Burda said. "In the postseason, that ingredient is already included in the mix."

The Mountain West Conference's replay system will incorporate a coaches' challenge, similar to the NFL's system. The Big 12 will allow on-field officials to assist the replay official in the press box. Conference USA will have its on-field officials conduct the review.

The main obstacle to overcome is deciding what system would be used in a bowl game involving teams from two different conferences and an officiating crew from a third league.

"They have to work out the logistics," Burda said.

But he said the conference commissioners are "optimistic they can get it worked out."

Link

I like the Mountain West Conference's way of doing it with a coaches challange. I hate the Big12's way of doing it.

 
And so was no helmets for a while. If you can improve the quality of the game by making sure that calls are made correctly, why not do it?

 
IMO I think many people are afraid it will make the game resemble a 12 inning baseball game with the score 0-0. I think every D1 team has examples where it could have many the diff in a game or two.

:horns2

GBR

me like it I wont ever argue against change for the better until proven otherwise <_<

or my wife tells me diff :lol:

 
You guys will thank us for instant reply. Well, you can thank Paterno since he is the reason it is being implemented. After years of getting shafted by Michigan and Ohio refs, enough was enough in 2002. All three losses were direct results of blown calls, in huge points in the games. 2 being in OT vs Iowa and Mich. Paterno went to the BigTen commission and bitched until he got some form of replay.

Last year, every single call that went to review was against PSU, and every single one was overturned. (didnt help the record obviously, but it does work, and it is much much faster than the pro system)

This was ruled a catch. Notice the ref. He is from Akron. This is in the 4th quarter. PSU lost 21-20.

11-01-03-FB-1031.jpg


 
This was ruled a catch. Notice the ref. He is from Akron. This is in the 4th quarter. PSU lost 21-20.

11-01-03-FB-1031.jpg
<Insert Picture from 1982 PSU-NU game here>

Sorry, no sympathy for you here man.

 
You betcha, but nothing can change it 23 years later. Instant replay is a good step towards preventing errors of that monstrosity from happening again.

 
Back
Top