my arguement wasnt for MU being in a playoff this year. It was just against the current system. As much as the Gator might like NU money more than MU money, THey like ND money the best. And that is stupid. Ticket sales will be the same and I believe people will watch a good game not a good name.
The BCS bowls are a joke most of the time. Although I agree those outside the 'big 6' should not be left out. Who in their right mind thinks some of the teams up there now, Utah, BYU,Boise & Ball State are really better than LSU, Oklahoma St, Florida, MU, Georgia & USC. ONLY the top 14 in the BCS rankings qualify. So why limit it to two teams per conference? I thought it was for the best teams. The Big 12 has 5 of those 14 teams, the SEC 3. Why does a #21 Pitt, #20 FSU or #16 North Carolina get a BCS bid while either Texas, TT or Oklahoma don't. THAT is my main issue. They build this system as the way to get the best teams, but your starting point in preseason determines where you end as much as anything else. That doesnt make you the best team. And then when they get their rankings, they only follow them for one game. Truth is most years you would be more likely to see Georgia/Hawaii instead of Boise/Oklahoma.
I am a D-II guy. The playoffs are awsome. The regular season still counts for everything, if you dont win you dont get in. I am not sure how they could slot the system in D-I. Conference winners then fill in with the tops from the BCS I suppose. Nobody will truely be happy. But if I get the chance to see BYU prove they are better than USC that is what matters to me. Good teams will move on and you will in most cases end up with the best two.