From what I've seen of your work, any highlight reel would be awesome. Heck, you could make the offense look good...... ok, well, that may be stretching it.
I'm assuming there's no option to have HD content from this year AND last year because there is no HD content from last year? If so, go with the HD for the most part, maybe throw in some lower quality stuff if it's a really terrific play or it fits well. I'm looking forward to it.