Suh gets slapped

D

deedsker15

Starter
Rookie ratings for maddden 11

My link

Breakdown of attributes

My link

I know we all love Suh so this probably shocks you as much as it does me. The top rookie talent wise for madden the last several years except one, I believe, have been 87 overall, but this year they decided to make Suh only a 85. I posted the second link and in comparison to mccoy and they say mccoy has more power than Suh? Are they serious?

Comments anyone else?

 
deedsker15 said:
Rookie ratings for maddden 11

My link

Breakdown of attributes

My link

I know we all love Suh so this probably shocks you as much as it does me. The top rookie talent wise for madden the last several years except one, I believe, have been 87 overall, but this year they decided to make Suh only a 85. I posted the second link and in comparison to mccoy and they say mccoy has more power than Suh? Are they serious?

Comments anyone else?
Click to expand...
maybe because the last several rookies were more of offensive stars like rb/qb/wr no love for the lineman? I dunno.

 
well i think the overall rating is pretty good but I don't understand why they have the agi and str disparity between him and McCoy.

 
Probably because it's a video game. Competitive balance matters more than individual accuracy.

 
In Madden ratings, that's actually "Power Moves". Suh is given a higher strength rating at 95-89, and much better block shedding.

Here's the top 8 DT's for reference

Top Defensive Tackles

K. Williams – 97

V. Wilfork – 95

J. Ratliff – 94

K. Jenkins – 94

S. Rogers – 93

C. Hampton – 91

A. Franklin – 90

R. Starks – 89

 
I don't really see it as a slap. Suh is a rookie, who hasn't played a single down in the NFL. Like it or not, he hasn't proved a single thing in the NFL yet. I'm sure he'll be a great one, but until he does something, I'll say that an 85 is a fair rating.

 
because Madden's not a good game, I was hoping backbreaker would take off and force EA to actually try for once.

 
jliehr said:
In Madden ratings, that's actually "Power Moves". Suh is given a higher strength rating at 95-89, and much better block shedding.

Here's the top 8 DT's for reference

Top Defensive Tackles

K. Williams – 97

V. Wilfork – 95

J. Ratliff – 94

K. Jenkins – 94

S. Rogers – 93

C. Hampton – 91

A. Franklin – 90

R. Starks – 89
Click to expand...
i meant power moves, but you know what happens when you get to typing...what i was saying is that i have seen a lot of film between the two of them and i don't see how on earth you can say mccoy has a better power move than suh...suh simply locks on you then pushes you where he wants you...suh's bull rush, what i consider the primary power move, is far superior to mccoy

 
Ringer02 said:
because Madden's not a good game, I was hoping backbreaker would take off and force EA to actually try for once.
Click to expand...

I agree, while Backbreaker is pretty fun and revolutionary, it is missing a lot. I hope EA sees the light and purchases the rights to the physics engine or develops something similar.

 
according too the attributes they are saying Suh is stronger. But they are also saying McCoy is faster. i don't entirely agree with that. but stuff like this happens when you have a monopoly over an entire Genre in gaming. It sucks.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top