Warner better than Manning

[BIGREDFAN_in_OMAHA]

Besides being true I also like to see one of the precious Mannings get bashed:

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/foot...chff/index.html

 

[WVhuskerXX]

no way....

 

[HUSKER 37]

Shows hw much Media Hype can still affect perceptions even if the stats don't support them.

Before reading the article, I was thinking to myself, If they were both graduating from college today, I'd pick Warner..But for some reason, I thought Peyton was much younger than Warner, so I probably would trade for Manning.

But they came out around the same time...Warner it is.

Now... what to do with Leinart?

 

[MUTigerFan]

Shows hw much Media Hype can still affect perceptions even if the stats don't support them.

Before reading the article, I was thinking to myself, If they were both graduating from college today, I'd pick Warner..But for some reason, I thought Peyton was much younger than Warner, so I probably would trade for Manning.

But they came out around the same time...Warner it is.

Now... what to do with Leinart?

Manning is 5 years younger. They came into the NFL at the same time, they didn't come out (of college) at the same time. Warner was cut from the NFL, then played arena FB.

 

[redout22]

As of now I would pick Warner. Manning doesn't have Fitzgerald though.