which is better?

sd'sker

sd'sker

Banned
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?

 
The only good thing about going to Indy and losing would be the novelty of being the only team to have gone to two different conference's first ever championship games.

I would take the BCS bowl choice every time.

 
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
Personally....I would prefer NU get a BSC bowl bid...but the stars would have to really aligned for NU. Lose to Mich in Ann Arbor? Then have almost every top 10 team lose a game. It's highly doubtful.

 
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
I'll just throw this out there: it's not an option because if we don't win the B1G, it is highly unlikely that we would get a BCS bid given the perception of the conference.

 
Hey it could happen, Arky got one last year and besides I think you all will make it to Indy anyhow

 
HuskerShark said:
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
I'll just throw this out there: it's not an option because if we don't win the B1G, it is highly unlikely that we would get a BCS bid given the perception of the conference.
Click to expand...
it's a hypothetical. i wanted to ask which would be better, winning the B1G champ. or a bcs game.

 
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
A BCS victory would be better.

 
Husker_x said:
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
A BCS victory would be better.
Click to expand...
what about a bcs loss or a chance in indy (and with this hypothetical, winning does not mean a bcs bid).

 
sd said:
Husker_x said:
sd said:
i was wondering what people thought about these two possibilities:

which would be better; NU getting to indy, losing, going to a second tier bowl, or NU finishing 10-2, missing out on indy, and going to a bcs bowl?
Click to expand...
A BCS victory would be better.
Click to expand...
what about a bcs loss or a chance in indy (and with this hypothetical, winning does not mean a bcs bid).
Click to expand...
Winning in Indy does mean a BCS bid.

 
boy oh boy, you guys struggle with a hypothetical. what i want to know is which is more meaningful, by itself in a vacuum, a bcs game or going to indy. and then, a bcs win or a win in indy.

 
sd said:
boy oh boy, you guys struggle with a hypothetical. what i want to know is which is more meaningful, by itself in a vacuum, a bcs game or going to indy. and then, a bcs win or a win in indy.
Click to expand...
Hypothetically... could we lose to Northwestern... then still play for the national championship?

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top