The top 8 of the list are shoo-ins for sure. No brainers.
The next 8 are iffy, but possibly warrant inclusion.
- Washington and Auburn simply are not at the level of the other 16 on this list.
- I would disqualify Penn St, because without Paterno that program is nothing, and Paterno can burn in hell.
- The others are all up there in terms of total # of wins, and bowl wins and appearances. Tennessee and Georgia don't have the same championship hardware as the others but lots of wins.
- Florida, FSU, Miami, LSU, and Clemson all have multiple national championships spanning multiple coaches, but they don't have the same historical pedigree as the top 8. They are a solid second-tier historically. More of a new-money vs old-money sort of deal.