Who will win, and who SHOULD win?

[Minnesota_husker]

Those who say Gerhart dont deserve it are flat wrong, but Suh deserves it more. Honestly if suh loses to Gerhart it doesnt bug me, because that kid had one hell of a season.

 

[RedDenver]

Those who say Gerhart dont deserve it are flat wrong, but Suh deserves it more. Honestly if suh loses to Gerhart it doesnt bug me, because that kid had one hell of a season.

Gerhart is worthy of the Heisman, IMO, but Ingram is not. Nor is McCoy or Tebow. Helu has almost as many yards as Ingram. But Ingram is averaging over 6 ypc, while Gerhart has just over 5 ypc. I just can't see how any of those guys even holds a candle to Suh. My Heisman ballot would look like this:

1) Suh

2) Kellen Moore

3) Gerhart

 

[huskerjack23]

Here's my Heisman ballot. And this would be legit without bias...

1) Suh

2) No one else.

Suh is the only one who had a monster type season worthy of heisman candidacy.