Another head scratcher.....thought we were going to blow it again, glad we didn't.
Yup, there were several more sequences in the course of the game where you really just scratch your head and wonder WTH? The failure to ram the ball in on first and goal from the 4 with Imani Cross that turned into a pick and could have been pick 6 for MSU was horrible. That got boos from about 50,000 fans too who recognized the brainless calls immediately. The squib kick instead of kicking deep is really very tough for me. If they needed a TD, I could consider the squib theory. I think you squib kick with less than 10 seconds left and or no time outs. You are trying to burn clock and maybe even use it up with the return being the final play. In this case, they used a sum total of 3 seconds and got a gift of about 15 yards of good field position. Additionally, the biggest problem with unorthodox kick offs of any kind is that the often create unusual returns and coverage mix ups as the timing is often abnormal and can create big return possibilities, much like the cases where the kick returner mishandles to catch of the ball on the kick, often dropping it for a couple seconds, allowing the return coverage guys to respond and converge prematurely. This often leaves gaps and lanes in the field for big returns to be made.
The best strategy in my opinion is to kick off deep and out of the end zone if possible. You want to avoid giving the opponent any extra chances for 'big' plays. Kick returns tend to be 'all or nothings' and game breakers if the returner breaks through the initial wave/wall of would be tacklers. Let your defense get set up and prevent the big play. You want to force the offense to have to use several plays to move down the field, using up the clock in the process.
I know this is rather rudimentary and presumably is obvious to the readers but I am expecting perhaps someone who supports the squib kick approach Riley/Company used will explain to me and others what the logic is for using this squib kick. Of course, if the answer is that Brown messed up and was supposed to kick the ball differently, perhaps further down the field or in a different way or trajectory, etc, then that may be find and dandy. But, you better have a senior kicker who has a bunch more experience and lots of practice because you are gambling the entire outcome of the game on his ability to perform magic with the kicked ball. Brown, to date, has not demonstrated to me, he is that kind of special / gifted kicker.