Top Five All Time B1G O linemen

TGHusker

Heisman Trophy Winner
http://espn.go.com/blog/bigten/post/_/id/133020/ranking-the-big-tens-top-5-all-time-offensive-linemen

It is good to see the Huskers dominate this important area. 3 Huskers and 2 Buckeyes hold the top 5. Pace from OSU is # 1 but I'll play homer here and state I think Remington deserves that distinction. Dean Steinkuhler (Mr Fubmlerooski) and Aaron Taylor are 4&4 You know that is a pretty good top 5 when Will Shields is 'only' Honorable Mention

I think this is probably one of the best/strongest All Time Groups listed. One could argue that these 5 would easily all be in a national Top 10 all time and maybe all in a top 7-8. Having OL close to this caliber would be the 1st step in getting us back into the NC discussion. It all starts upfront.

1. Orlando Pace, Ohio State, 1994-96: Forget the Big Ten. Pace was the greatest offensive lineman in the history of college football. He became the first sophomore to ever win the Lombardi, and he followed that up the next season by winning the Lombardi, Outland and finishing fourth in the Heisman Trophy voting. Said former Ohio State coach John Cooper: "Orlando Pace is not only the best offensive lineman I have ever coached, but he is the best I have ever seen." Pace helped popularize the "pancake" stat and did not allow a sack in his last two seasons. He was selected No. 1 overall in the 1997 NFL draft.

2. Dave Rimington, Nebraska, 1979-82: In the Outland Trophy's 70 years of existence, only one player has ever won the award in back-to-back years: Rimington. The Nebraska native, who played his entire career with a torn ACL, also won the Lombardi in 1982 and finished fifth in the Heisman voting. "For a big guy, Dave was the quickest guy I've ever seen," then-coach Tom Osborne said. Rimington was the greatest college center of all-time, so it's only natural the annual award for college's top center is named the "Rimington Trophy." The Big Ten's annual award for the top offensive lineman also is named after Rimington, along with Pace.

3. Jim Parker, Ohio State, 1954-56: We already mentioned college football's best-ever tackle and center -- so why not arguably the top guard? In 1956, Parker finished eighth in the Heisman voting and became the first Buckeye to win the Outland. He was huge for his time period but, as his College Football Hall of Fame bio noted, he was still "cat-quick." Ohio State's Woody Hayes even called him the best lineman he ever coached. "Physically, Jim was in a class by himself," Hayes once said. "Attitude-wise, he was even greater. You only had to tell him once."

4. Dean Steinkuhler, Nebraska, 1980-83: He won both the Outland and Lombardi as a senior, making him just one of just five offensive linemen to ever win both awards. And, although he played with Rimington, one 1983 newspaper account said Steinkuhler consistently graded higher. Said Osborne: "He is strong and very intelligent, and you just don't find guys that size who could move like that." He was named to both the Walter Camp and Sports Illustrated all-century teams, and he's believed to come from the smallest town to ever produce an All-American (Burr, Nebraska; population of about 100). Still, he might be best known for the 1984 Orange Bowl's "Fumblerooski," where he picked up a TD.

5. Aaron Taylor, Nebraska, 1994-97: He was a two-time consensus All-American as a junior and senior and, as a sophomore, he was even named a third-team All-American by the Football News. It was unusual for Taylor not to knock a defender on the ground, whether he was playing guard or center. He had at least 100 pancakes every season as a starter and, in those three years, compiled 378 pancakes. (Although not an official stat, Ohio State recorded Pace's junior pancake total at 80.) Taylor won the Outland in 1997, the teams he played on finished with a 49-2 career record, and Nebraska retired his jersey less than a year after his final college game. Like Steinkuhler, Taylor was also a unanimous all-century pick.

Honorable mentions: John Hicks, Ohio State; Tony Mandarich, Michigan State; d!(k Wildung, Minnesota; Will Shields, Nebraska; Tom Brown, Minnesota

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Will Shield could easily be top 5 but still cool to see us take 3 out of 5 spots.
Yes, who would / could you drop out to move him in?
default_dunno.gif
He's got to be # 6 in my book.

 
Will Shield could easily be top 5 but still cool to see us take 3 out of 5 spots.
Yes, who would / could you drop out to move him in?
default_dunno.gif
He's got to be # 6 in my book.
Again you can look at it a few ways. Only considering college like the list is or considering their overall careers. Obviously Shields continued his success in the NFL. He has always been one of our best linemen imo but don't get me wrong Rimington and Steinkuler are locks and Taylor was a beast. They're all great linemen.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
was sad about Aaron Taylor and his rings getting auctioned off.

Glad to see so many Cornhuskers on list....so many good ones

 
So the author goes on-and-on about how Pace is the greatest O-lineman ever. Then, he later talks about how Pace popularized the "pancake stat" but says that Aaron Tayler had 100 each year he started but Pace only had 80 his Junior year?

Rimington is obviously the best O-lineman ever in college football history. whoever wrote this understands how great he was but relegates him to his position rather than overall. That is just stupid. I am old enough to remember both players. Yes I am a Nebraska homer...but regardless, Pace looks big and doughy compared to Rimington. And Rimington changed games from his position. Pace contributed.

I guess you can't make a "Best ever" list for the B1G and then fill it with guys who played for the Big-8/12, but I would have put Zach Wiegart and Will Shields on this list and left the osu guys off the list completely.
default_nutkick.gif


oh and in honor of this being an O-line thread....here is the obligatory bunny with a pancake
default_pancakebunny.gif


 
Back
Top