Scratchtown
All-Conference
Kelly's recruiting was better, yes. However of all the 4 and 5 stars recruited.Kelly first three years recruiting: 13th...9th...16th...The second thing he talked about and something I've read a lot of lately... is the fan and media unhappiness with the Oregon program... because the current coaching staff does not appear to be living up to the standard set by Chip Kelly. Sound familiar? That's pretty much the exact same thing that Nebraska fans have been going through for 18 years and it's the exact same reaction of Alabama fans... Ohio State fans and the fans of any and all programs that had former great success. So the claim that only Nebraska fans act that way is nonsense and that only Nebraska fans expect "too much" is also nonsense. It's the nature of sports and fans. It's the natural way for fans to react.
It's pretty damn absurd.
Kelly first 3 years
10-3
12-1
12-2
3 conference championships, 1 national championship game appearance, 1 rose bowl win, 1 rose bowl loss
wins over (at the time, and in order) the #18, #6, #4, #13, #9, #24, #21, #18, #3, and #9 ranked teams.
Helfrich first 3 years
11-2
13-2
9-4
1 conference championship, 1 national championship game appearance, 1 alamo bowl win, 1 alamo bowl loss
wins over (at the time, and in order) the #16, #12, #7, #18, #17, #8, #2, and #22 ranked teams.
It's not as good, certainly, but if the expectation is a conference championship, title game appearance or rose bowl appearance every single year then Oregon will throw itself back into mediocrity by not knowing how good they have it.
Helfrich first three years recruiting: 23rd...17th... 28th...
What I've read from many Oregon fans is.... it's the momentum thing. A slip in recruiting and a 9-4 record has fans and media feeling the Big Mo slipping away. Momentum is a very strong beast.
Pretty much like many Nebraska fans felt with Solich. All typical fan reactions. We'll just have to see if the sentiment is right or wrong.
In 2010 there were four 4 stars (out of 10) that didn't make it, and the lone 5 star that transferred to Baylor (Lache Seastrunk)
2011 there were again four 4 stars (out of 11) that didn't make it or didn't contribute at all and 1 (out of 2) 5 stars left the team in 2013 (Colt Lyerla) (Tra Carson also left for TAMU but was a 3 star)
2012 there were ten 4 stars and 2 of them left the team or didn't make it, and another 2 missed at least 1 season with ACL or Broken Leg's (Bralon Addison, and Pharaoh Brown)
Attrition was above average in those classes if you count the entire class (not just the 4 and 5 stars)
For Helfrich 2013 was mostly a class of Chip Kelly's doing.
Attrition is much lower. Just by eyeballing it I can see the attrition rate is much lower.
Kelly did recruit better but he lost more kids or kids never showed up more under him than they do for Helfrich. What does that mean? Pshh, I don't know if it means anything 100 percent. I would think though that it would be sort of an equalizer though.
So really, I think Helf is working with the same or better talent actually than what Kelly was. Following them for more than 10-12 years the skill position talent is better at a whole than they have ever had. The biggest difference between the 2 era's comes down to another coaching position and it's not Head Coach, or Offensive Coordinator.
Nick Aliotti retiring was a much BIGGER reason for the Duck's "struggles" under Helfrich, than Kelly leaving. Oregon has an offensive identity that has stayed consistent since his departure. Don Pellum the defensive coordinator the last 2 seasons was a huge reason for the struggle. Along side with Frost's inability to develop QB's
A lot of Oregon people are upbeat about bringing in Brady Hoke because of the stats of his defenses at Michigan, and other places he has been. The addition of renown QB coach David Yost, who many people around the country think he's one of the best QB coaches, should help the young QB's develop.