I know that some here really are against 3 star players, but is a guy that runs a 4.3 and 10.6, and #2 Juco WR good enough even tho he is only a 3 star???? This might be another reason that possibly the services don't always get it right.
I don't care if I NEVER see another jet sweep in my life. Hip Hip.....We will if we don't have a running QB.
It's probably a case of they matter when you are getting them and don't when you're not and need justification for a class still being good. In the end development is key either way. I think you do need some top end talent that can be the face of a class but athletes like this can be game changers and pieces needed for a program to make a jump.I had this discussion in another thread where a member thought we needed to get 4-5 star players to win and discounted 3 star players. I am trying to make the point that stars do not always matter.
The services don't always catch the top end talent. Usually the 5 star guys are almost a sure thing if they stay out of trouble, but there are lots of 4 star busts.It's probably a case of they matter when you are getting them and don't when you're not and need justification for a class still being good. In the end development is key either way. I think you do need some top end talent that can be the face of a class but athletes like this can be game changers and pieces needed for a program to make a jump.
I completely agree. I don't think the difference between 3 and 4 stars is all that vast in a lot of cases and some of the ratings bumps are based on camps.The services don't always catch the top end talent. Usually the 5 star guys are almost a sure thing if they stay out of trouble, but there are lots of 4 star busts.
And there are many reasons that star ratings coming out of high school aren't the final say in how well a kid plays in college. For some the light finally goes on and their mind catches up to their physical skill. For others their body matures or maybe they get serious about weight training for the first time. The one day snap shot that rating services get to view a kid at a camp is often far from reality. I'd much rather trust our coaches to see if the kid fits in their system.I had this discussion in another thread where a member thought we needed to get 4-5 star players to win and discounted 3 star players. I am trying to make the point that stars do not always matter.
I don't care if I NEVER see another jet sweep in my life. Hip Hip.....
You can play this game all day long.Abdullah was a 3 star. End of conversation.