caveman99
All-American
One is able to bring new 5 star recruits, the other just plays. Sure their performance can be a draw, but the coach has to make the sell. Besides you are assuming that the 5 stars would all live up to their potential under a different coach. I would submit MR, Texas, LSU, etc. as examples of under achievers.Assuming those kids win (they would), their impact also lasts on.