1) There is no proof whatsoever Chadwell's stuff wouldn't work in the B1G. Part of it is RPO, which Minnesota, Penn State, and a few others utilize to some degree of success. According to your logic, against all these NFL caliber defenders, nothing will work. Minnesota just went up and down the field with an average QB against us running some RPO. And we did run some option plays successfully against nearly every team we've played. Frost just doesn't call it often enough to get a real read on how effective it actually is as an offense. No play is going 20+ yards every time, and while the option does get stopped at times, it's still an effective play, and offense.
2)Army, Navy, and Air Force are almost always out-matched athletically, but somehow, they have winning records and make bowl games. They move the ball. They keep their defense fresh. They keep themselves in most games. A struggling, rebuilding Navy squad beat Malzahn's high-flying UCF Knights a couple weeks ago. Air Force just beat Boise State by a touchdown, the same Boise State that bested a previously undefeated BYU. In 2019, after Colorado beat us in overtime, Air Force beat them. Army marched (pun intended) into Camp Randall and fell by 6. They moved the ball on the Badgers, though out-sized and out-matched athletically. Imagine what could be done with Husker size, strength, and speed if they had someone to coach them to be steady, disciplined, and consistent?
3) Paul Johnson at Georgia Tech proved that an option offense at the FBS level can be somewhat successful. They did hit plateaus here and there, but the Yellowjackets won the Orange Bowl, set rushing records, beat Florida State, Georgia, etc.
4) I don't get the resistance, either from Frost, or a large segment of the fans, to going back to a ground-based attack that includes option in some form or fashion. We've literally done about everything EXCEPT that since '03, and what success is there to show for it? Literally, how much worse could things be? a 4-8 season?
It's simple. Nebraska football is NEVER going to return to any kind of real success until whoever is coaching is 100% committed to establishing a running attack as our IDENTITY. The 'N' on the side of the helmet NEEDS to mean hard-nosed, smash-mouth football, or we'll be watching everyone else come bowl season every year.
We need to go back.