Well, back in the '70s, two kickers - one from Arkansas named Steve Little and the other from Texas named Russel Erklaban or something like that - seemed to be in a kicking duel, with both ending up kicking 67 yarders.
Of course, they kicked using "broken in" balls, and had tees. But it was enough that Grant Teaff of Baylor, who was on the NCAA Competition Committee pushed through the provision to remove tees, if I recall correctly.
Collegiate
69 yards: Ove Johansson, Abilene Christian (W 17–0) v East Texas State, October 16, 1976 (2-inch tee) Shotwell Stadium, Abilene. NAIA.
67 yards: Russell Erxleben, Texas (W 72–15) v Rice, October 1, 1977 (2-inch tee)
67 yards: Steve Little, Arkansas (L 9–13) v Texas, October 15, 1977 (2-inch tee)
67 yards: Joe Williams, Wichita State (W 33–7) v Southern Illinois, October 21, 1978 (2-inch tee)
67 yards: Tom Odle, Fort Hays State (W 22–14) v Washburn, November 5, 1988 (2-inch tee), NCAA Division II.
67 yards: Mike Billengas, Tecnologico de Monterrey Campus Mexico City ([Mexico City, Mexico]) (L 22–14) v UVM (MEX), July 27, 2006[citation needed]
65 yards: John Triplett Haxall, Princeton (L 1g,1s-2g,2t,1s) v Yale, November 30, 1882 (w/out tee) The Polo Grounds, 5th Avenue at 110th Street, New York City. [2]
65 yards: J.P. Ross, Birmingham A.C. (W 5–4) v Alabama, November 12, 1892 (drop-kick)
65 yards: Tony Franklin, Texas A&M (W 24–0) v Baylor, October 16, 1976 (2-inch tee)
(after Johansson's 69–yarder)
65 yards: Martin Gramatica, Kansas State (W 73–7) v Northern Illinois September 12, 1998 (longest in NCAA history without a tee)
64 yards: Jose Martinez, UTEP (W 58–13) v UCF, September 27, 2008
64 yards: Tony Franklin, Texas A&M (W 24–0) v Baylor, October 16, 1976 (2-inch tee)
(before Johansson's 69–yarder)
64 yards: Russell Erxleben, Texas (W 13–6) v Oklahoma (2-inch tee) October 8, 1977
63 yards: Morten Andersen, Michigan State, at Ohio State, September 19, 1981
63 yards: Joe Duren, Arkansas State (W 22–20) v McNeese State, November 23, 1974 (2-inch tee) NCAA Division II
63 yards: Scott Roper, Arkansas State (W 27–20) v North Texas State, November 7, 1987 (2-inch tee) NCAA Division 1-AA [1]
63 yards: Bill Gramática, South Florida v. Austin Peay, November 18, 2000 (longest field goal at sea level w/o tee in NCAA history)
62 yards: Jason Hanson, Washington State University vs. University of Nevada at Las Vegas, September 28, 1991 (w/o tee)
62 yards: Derek Doerfler, Baker University vs. William Jewell College, 2007
61 yards: Ralf Mojsiejenko, Michigan State, at Illinois, September 11, 1982
61 yards: Bill Shear, Cortland State (NY) vs. Hobart, 1966. 1st 60+ yard field goal at any level of organized football
61 yards: Steve Little, Arkansas (L 9–3) v Tulsa, September 25, 1976 (2-inch tee)
60 yards: Bill McClard, Arkansas (W 36–3) v SMU, November 14, 1970 (2-inch tee)
60 yards: Russell Erxleben, Texas (W 26–0) v Texas Tech October 29, 1977
60 yards: Kevin Butler, Georgia (W 26–23) v. Clemson 1984
60 yards: Pete Garces, Idaho State v Cal State Northridge, 1998
60 yards: Mason Crosby, Colorado v Iowa State, 2004
60 yards: Gary Cismesia, Florida State University (L 12–45) vs. University of Florida, 2007
59 yards: Jan Stenerud, Montana State v Montana, 1964
59 yards: Joe Petrone, Idaho State (W 53–32)v Portland state, 1968
59 yards: Ralf Mojsiejenko, Michigan State, at Purdue, October 1, 1983
59 yards: Cloyce Hinton, Ole Miss v Georgia, October 11, 1969
59 yards: Jared Siegel, Oregon v UCLA , 2002
58 yards: Jon Bacon, University of Cincinnati (T 17–17) @ Miami, Ohio 1994
58 yards: Mason Crosby, Colorado (L 23–3) @ Miami, 2005
57 yards: Morten Andersen, Michigan State, at Michigan, October 1, 1980
57 yards: Gene Branum, Austin College (T 24–24) v Concordia College, December 12, 81 (NAIA Division II National Championship Game)
57 yards: Ryan Harrison, Air Force (W 20–17) v Texas Christian, September 13, 2007
57 yards: Derek Doerfler, Baker University vs. Culver-Stockton College, 2007