Mel Kiper vs. Mcshay

B

bo knows

Walk-on
They were asked who the heisman frontrunner is in their opinion and McShay made the case for Alabama's running back and Mel Kiper states that he believes that Suh should be in the discussion and makes the point that just because Nebraska is not in the National Title race and he is not an offensive skill player that his talent should not be over looked and Suh should be considered for the award.

 
Mel Kiper and Todd McShay just had a debate about the Heisman this year, and Mel Kiper was giving Suh some hype, saying that just because Suh isnt a skill player and is not a NC contender doesnt mean he is not the best player in the nation.

McShay was just being realistic and saying that the Heisman winner will come from Florida, Texas, or Alabama, and he will play either QB or RB.

Just thought that some of you would like to know that Suh is getting a little respect out there in the Media and specifically from someone who works for ESPN

 
Last edited by a moderator:
well, out of everything I have seen this year so far, Suh deserves it more than anyone else...

Sipple chose Jimmy Clausen, you got that running back dude from Alabama, Colt McCoy, and Tebow...

None of those guys are really lighting it up.

Suh is getting double teamed and still has good stats.. he's worthy of it in my book, and skill player or not, he's got major skills.

 
bo knows said:
They were asked who the heisman frontrunner is in their opinion and McShay made the case for Alabama's running back and Mel Kiper states that he believes that Suh should be in the discussion and makes the point that just because Nebraska is not in the National Title race and he is not an offensive skill player that his talent should not be over looked and Suh should be considered for the award.
Click to expand...

VOTE FOR NDAMUKONG SUH FOR THE HEISMAN

SUH is the current leader but the others are gaining on him.

They had him in the pick list but took him out, apparently they don't

want him to win.

As the presenting sponsor for the Heisman Trophy,

Nissan has the unique privilege of casting one official

vote for the winner of the Heisman Trophy.

You are limited to one (1) vote per day.

Help Suh get his due. Copy, paste & vote daily In the TYPE YOUR NOMINEE HERE box

Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska

http://promo.espn.go.com/espn/contests/the...vote/2009/index

 
I've felt this way for awhile, but now that were talking about it, Kiper is probably the top guy in evaluating talent. McShay comes off like he's there just for the cameras.

 
Dude on the Big 12 show on Fox Sports last night said that Suh is the best player in the nation and has been all year. I think it was Watson’s boy Joel Klatt.

 
HuckFoley said:
well, out of everything I have seen this year so far, Suh deserves it more than anyone else...

Sipple chose Jimmy Clausen, you got that running back dude from Alabama, Colt McCoy, and Tebow...

None of those guys are really lighting it up.

Suh is getting double teamed and still has good stats.. he's worthy of it in my book, and skill player or not, he's got major skills.
Click to expand...
Clausen's only getting pub cause he's a golden-domer. I would argue that Shipley has done more for Texas than Ingram from Alabama or Tebow for Florida. It sickens me how much the media determines who should be in the race.

 
If the Heisman was awarded for its intended reason - to recognize the best play in college football for that year - then Suh should definitely be considered. However, it's more a popularity contest than anything.

I have not taken the Heisman award seriously since 1995.

 
I'm with Michael on this one. Eddie George over Tommie was rediculous. Then we had Woodsen over Peyton Manning 2 years later. It's a popularity contest and they get it right about 10 percent of the time.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top