Haha! Somone voted FSU at #1!? Here's a convo. I had with a buddy of mine on facebook who is a diehard FSU fan. He is actually very knowledgeable about football, yet has never strapped up in pads a day in his life. I love the guy, but he drinks waaay too much of the FSU kool-aid and I've told him that FSU has been one of the highest underachieving teams in the past decade. I've put him in his place before and have pissed him off when I've told him that FSU recruits top 5 to top 10 talent, yet doesn't produce SQUAT in terms of team success on the field. He thinks his team has the right coaches this year to bring them back to prominence....I'll hold my breath on that.
Here it is. He sent me a link that has FSU's defensive line ranked in the top 10 followed by his comment. Then the debate commenced:
Me: Tons o talent and potential that's for sure (year in and year out with recruiting)....but can the coaching/development bring them back to prominence? We will see sir. Plus there are so many other elements that come into play to make a great team. NEB will never be able to recruit like the Noles, however, I think a few diamonds each year coupled with our current culture/staff, can bring NEB to a BCS title game.
Him: LOL, ok now you're reaching. In the last ten years tell me who won the national title that wasn't loaded.
Me: I am basing it off of past recruiting rankings. Even NEB didn't deliver a top 5 to top 10 recruiting class when they dominated in '94 and '95. However, NEB was LOADED with talent on both sides of the ball. My point is....it's coaching, development, culture and all the other aspects as well that bring the team together for optimal success. Teams in the past such as Boise St, Wiscy, TCU have mediocre recruiting seasons, ie 30 to 60th in recruiting rankings, yet produce very good quality teams that can contend in BCS title games. NEB develops talent, ie Suh, Amukamara, Dennard, David, Helu, etc. David was a 2-start athlete, Dennard and Amukamara were both 3-stars according to rivals I believe. As you know, it's not all about recruiting stars. FSU should know this quite well by now considering the past 10 years, they have had HUGE success with recruiting talent/potential, yet have fallen short in becoming a successful team in regards to the win/loss column. FSU needs to get over that hump and start showing me that they can be the team they have the potential to be based on the high talent/potential they recruit.
Him: Yep, and you can blame that on the former regim that was around too long. Since Fisher came in they are back in the top 10 consistently, won both bowl games, 4-0 against Miami and Florida don't have to tell me about development. I could say the same about your Huskers about showing me they can play up to higher standards I was in Madison last year for that debacle. Whether anyone wants to admit it or not, stars matter. The D-Line is full of absolute ballers!
Me: Stars matter to an extent. LSU and Alabama would agree that stars matter, yet they have amazing coaching as well. I want to see FSU in a BCS title game with all this talent. It's put up or shut-up for not only FSU, but NEB as well in my opinion. I can't wait for the season to start. I think FSU has the potential to make it to a BCS game this year, we'll see.