What a wonderfully misleading thread title.
I was OK, not thrilled, with cally. Offense did its job for the most part, but he was WAY too loyal to cosgrove. After a couple of seasons, or at least 1/2 way through last season, callahan should have fired himtrue, if we had to do it all over again, Solich would have been given 2 more years. although he was a poor recruiter and had a lack of imagination, he was slowly making changes here.....water over the damn though, so speculation is irrelevant, but i will say, callahan's style was a total mismatch.