You guys joined the Big Ten at a 20-year nadir, imo. From the early 1990's through the late 00's there were usually 2 elite teams and 2 or 3 more clear top 25-teams: Ohio State, Michigan, PSU + two from Iowa, Wiscy, Illinois, MSU, Minny, NW, etc. During this time, the Big Ten's perception didn't match its true talent level, imo. A lot of this stemmed from a very tough bowl slate (made worse by almost always putting two teams in BCS games which moved others up a notch), inherent geographic bowl game disadvantage and unusually long wait from season's end till the high-profile bowl games. Ohio State had something like a 45 day break between Michigan '06 and the MNC game. The conference championship does something to address the last bit, at least.The way I would describe the B1G is that the peaks aren't as high as the other conferences but the valleys don't seem to be as low either.i am just speaking in general. a lot of two loss teams and teams that just do not meet the eye-test.Based on the top 25 I would say the SEC, Pac 12 and ACC (FSU #2, Clemson #8) are all doing pretty good compared to the Big 10. Even the Big 12 has more ranked teams than the Big 10 currently except in the coaches poll where Minnesota eaked out Georgia for the #25th spot this week.
Overall, the B10 has a better BCS record than the B12 and the ACC despite playing tougher match ups. Everyone points to OSU's flops in the 06 and 07 title games, but they're 6-3 in BCS games. Plus, some of those PSU, Iowa and Michigan squads that got handled by USC in Los Angeles were very, very good, and just didn't look the same come early January. Not taking anything from those USC squads. They were elite. But mid-season match-ups without the extreme geography disadvantage would have been interesting.
The Tatgate scandal, Rich Rod's disastrous tenure at Michigan and the Sandusky nightmare created a mammoth vacuum during your first years in the Big Ten. Only OSU seems to have recovered. Even Iowa hasn't looked anything but mediocre since the GT Orange Bowl win. Overall, the B10 is down, unquestionably, and bad bowl seasons highlighted by Wisconsin's three consecutive Rose Bowl losses (by less than 20 points combined, ouch!) have made things worse. Hoping a good bowl season performance will shake some of the negative vibes.
Last edited by a moderator: