Did we deserve this win?

Status
Not open for further replies.
"if u dont love me now ull never love me again" what is wrong with u another big comeback win and ur still bitchin change ur period pad and get with the program

 
We scored 9 more points than they did. So yes, we deserve this win.

We have scored more than 8 other teams and scored less than 2 other teams, so yes, we are 8 - 2.

It's all very simple when you understand math.

 
honestly the fumble was the wrong call but there was no mistake. You have to have undisputable evidence to overturn a call. You couldn't tell with 100% certianty the exact moment the ball started coming out. It is unfortunate for Penn State case I believe they got screwed, but thats part of the game. I remember watching the Vikes get f'd out of a Super Bowl in the game against the Saints a couple years ago so I guess over time the calls even out

 
ndobney said:
honestly the fumble was the wrong call but there was no mistake. You have to have undisputable evidence to overturn a call. You couldn't tell with 100% certianty the exact moment the ball started coming out. It is unfortunate for Penn State case I believe they got screwed, but thats part of the game. I remember watching the Vikes get f'd out of a Super Bowl in the game against the Saints a couple years ago so I guess over time the calls even out
Click to expand...
I'm pretty sure that was more Favre's fault than the refs in that game.

 
ndobney said:
honestly the fumble was the wrong call but there was no mistake. You have to have undisputable evidence to overturn a call. You couldn't tell with 100% certianty the exact moment the ball started coming out. It is unfortunate for Penn State case I believe they got screwed, but thats part of the game. I remember watching the Vikes get f'd out of a Super Bowl in the game against the Saints a couple years ago so I guess over time the calls even out
Click to expand...
There was a linesman standing right on the goal line with a perfect view of the play and the ball. The main camera view that we could see in the replays was not shooting straight down the goal line, it was somewhat to the infield side of the goal line,,,,causing a small degree of paralax....in that case, I go with the man and his eyes that are in the right position...but it was hella close either way....and I'd be screaming mad if I were a Penn State fan....

 
Call the Big 10 Monday and say we don't want this win.....Just like the Seahawks turned down the win they got from the replacement officials....Oh wait, they didn't did they....

 
Finally found a GIF. Definitely a touchdown. Sucks to have a bad call (either way) on such a monumental swing play. We'll never know if we would've scored down 3 with 6-7 min. left.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
grandpasknee said:
ndobney said:
honestly the fumble was the wrong call but there was no mistake. You have to have undisputable evidence to overturn a call. You couldn't tell with 100% certianty the exact moment the ball started coming out. It is unfortunate for Penn State case I believe they got screwed, but thats part of the game. I remember watching the Vikes get f'd out of a Super Bowl in the game against the Saints a couple years ago so I guess over time the calls even out
Click to expand...
There was a linesman standing right on the goal line with a perfect view of the play and the ball. The main camera view that we could see in the replays was not shooting straight down the goal line, it was somewhat to the infield side of the goal line,,,,causing a small degree of paralax....in that case, I go with the man and his eyes that are in the right position...but it was hella close either way....and I'd be screaming mad if I were a Penn State fan....
Click to expand...
EXACTLY what I was saying during the game. The view was NOT right down the line, and yet the announcers were trying to make it out as though it was. Perspective in that situation becomes VERY deceiving. I agree, it was close, but without conclusive proof, you don't overturn that call.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top