That's easy. Riley wins because he has players that signed. Until players sign with Frost, we have no data to compare.
If you're speaking of offers and visits, I'd say Riley wins again,...everyone was pretty impressed with how little Riley was sleeping and how hard he was hitting the trail as well and he didn't have a bowl to coach in:
Now, I'm not saying Riley is better...I'm saying that the amount of sunshine pumping through this thread lacks perspective. Riley might have been a .500 coach but he didn't slouch on recruiting. His recruiting always impressed me because he ABSOLUTELY disproved Pelini's claim that you can't get higher star ranked kids to visit Nebraska.
Let's not act like he (Riley) was the worst at it and give credit where credit is due...as well as not giving too much credit where it isn't due (yet).