Here is my take on the Blackshirt thing. We all know the history. In practice, the coaches needed a way to distinguish the 1st team from 2nd team units etc. So the 1st team got the "Black shirts" and others got different colors. Simple, makes sense.
So here comes the debate: do you just give the black shirts to the starters as was done in the beginning, or do you regard the black shirt as some type of honor bestowed on only those deemed worthy? Coaches and fans have come down on both sides of this issue.
But here is the deal: 1st, the coaches have to be good enough to turn out a 1st team capable of top 10 national play. If they can do this, and give the Black shirts to that #1 unit, we are back to where this whole thing started. If you can earn a starting spot for Charlie McBride & Co. then yes, you are a Blackshirt, and by Golly, you deserved it. Practices were so hard, that the games were easy. The jersey was earned in practice, not the games, though it could be lost.
So how to handle the "Blackshirt" thing? It is moot if the coaches aren't focused on the right things and demanding enough.
But if the coaches ARE focused on the right things, following through with development of those things, and demanding enough of excellence, then earning (and continuing to earn) a starting spot justifies the shirt.
So here comes the debate: do you just give the black shirts to the starters as was done in the beginning, or do you regard the black shirt as some type of honor bestowed on only those deemed worthy? Coaches and fans have come down on both sides of this issue.
But here is the deal: 1st, the coaches have to be good enough to turn out a 1st team capable of top 10 national play. If they can do this, and give the Black shirts to that #1 unit, we are back to where this whole thing started. If you can earn a starting spot for Charlie McBride & Co. then yes, you are a Blackshirt, and by Golly, you deserved it. Practices were so hard, that the games were easy. The jersey was earned in practice, not the games, though it could be lost.
So how to handle the "Blackshirt" thing? It is moot if the coaches aren't focused on the right things and demanding enough.
But if the coaches ARE focused on the right things, following through with development of those things, and demanding enough of excellence, then earning (and continuing to earn) a starting spot justifies the shirt.