Shocked? By 7-5?
Let's see. We were 9-2 last year before the Big title game. We ended up with four losses. Not exactly miles away from five losses. Now think back to the regular season and tell me that there are not five games that we could have just as easily lost. Penn State, Northwestern, Michigaan State. Then throw in Michigan and Wisconsin the first time.
So yes 7-5 is plenty possible.
Rewind to 2001 pre black Friday. That was a shock. We really had not seen anything like that especially at the hands of CU.
The disappointments of the last 10 years have resulted in ever decreasing shock value.
We have been fairly mediocre. So a record reflective of a mediocre team would hardly be a shock.
Don't get me wrong. Heads would probably roll and we would all be disappointed but it would not be a shock.
We were 10-2 before the title game, and 2 of our 4 losses came in the postseason. So first of all, 2 losses in the regular season is quite a substantial ways away from 5.
Secondly, who cares what could have happened? The only thing that matters is what did happen. We won 10 games. 9 before that. 10, 10 and 9 before that.
We have been proven as a team that averages around 9.5 wins per year despite circumstances.
So yes, 7-5 would be a hell of a shock.