sd'sker
Banned
up was fantastic. i really haven't seen many movies within this year. if you like somewhat bizarre, but still good, i would recommend memento and the machinist. battlefield earth is on my watch instantly queue, but i don't know if it is bad enough to be good, or if it is just bad. i've been waiting for Cormac McCarthy's the road to come out on dvd.Haven't seen The Room, but I did see Battlefield Earth, which would be a close second to the best film ever made.that's great, fight club is probably my favorite movie. i also really enjoy jfk and casino (right now those may be my top three, it's a floating scale). those are the movies i can probably rewatch the most. of late, i was impressed with there will be blood, no country for old men, and the departed. but you are right, once it gets to the top 25, it is hard to rate. i place movies into tiers; but it is probably too idiosyncratic to explain. other than that it is mostly documentaries. i always enjoy a good movie; however, the best movie ever is 'the room', i hope you've seen it.Oh, it's a fun enough conversation to have, all right. I'm more of a film guy, really, so my experience of television is pretty limited compared to your average TV nut. IMO there's like a threshold, or a certain point where once a film has cracked into my top, say, 25, trying to decide the best becomes virtually impossible because I like them for different reasons. Citizen Kane, American Beauty and Fight Club, for example, are three of my favorite films. Which is the best? Uhhhhhh....what are we comparing, exactly?well i was just interest in people's opinions, i was not expecting a consensus, by any means. however, i would definitely recommend the wire to you, it may not surpass your love of the sopranos, but it will be worth your time. get back to me if you do start watching it. my wife has started watching the sopranos, and she has quickly become a fan.But how could The Wire be the greatest show ever when everyone who watches television (and nobody watched The Wire) knows that the Intergalactic English Dictionary defines the entry 'Greatest Television Show' as that mafia-based crime drama called The Sopranos which aired in the early part of the 21st century?
In all seriousness, though, I haven't watched The Wire, but HBO was born of a virgin and can commit no sin, so I'm sure it's balls-out awesome.
Having a conversation about the best TV show ever is ridiculous for two reasons. First, everyone knows it's The Sopranos and everyone else is in denial. And secondly, you might as well try to decide the best novel, best song, best form of government, best cigar, or best exotic cheese. Even if we try to abandon subjectivity––which we don't, no matter how much we pretend to (except in the case of The Sopranos, of course)––you'll still have to formulate the criterion we're evaluating. I can give you a dozen 'objective' reasons Shakespeare is the greatest dramatist in the English language, and yet if you ask me whether you should read Stephen King's IT or Shakespeare's 'Taming of the Shrew', and I'm going to give you King.
Tastes. All about tastes. And while I think there's definitely a difference in intellectual capacity between someone who thinks Friends is the greatest show ever and people who are talking about Dexter, Sopranos, Battlestar Galactica, or The Wire, it's a hard line to see sometimes.
Or The Godfather Parts I and II, which I recently watched on blu-ray for the first time. Both as close to perfect as films can get. Which is the better of the two, one might ask? Again, hard question, because they're extensions of the same story; and similarly American Beauty and Fight Club are extensions of the same theme. I personally would rather watch Godfather 1. I like the story a little better, and with every 'objective' category being virtually the same between the two, taste becomes the ultimate arbiter.
I'll PM you if I get to The Wire. LOST is just about finished taking a dump all over itself (what a sh**ty season #6 has been), and afterwards I'll probably need some new material.
Loved There Will Be Blood and No Country (and The Departed, for that matter). Recently Crazy Heart wasn't bad, and Pixar's UP was astounding. Going back a ways the most interesting movie I've seen in awhile is probably David Crongenberg's Dead Ringers, which was bizarrely awesome. Hurt Locker was a tad overrated IMO.
As far as documentaries go, I'm new to them but have watched quite a few recently. The best of the bunch that I've seen in the past few months was Brother's Keeper.
edit: and for documentaries, i would recommend the corporation and outfoxed (depending on your political leanings)
Last edited by a moderator: