I have tried to be careful in any criticism of the current staff and limit my negative remarks to only those obvious circumstances generally. This area is a concern. I know coaches can become overly scared of injurites as injuries to key or critical players and position groups can really hurt the team's chances. We all worry about injuries to the QB of course but any position can suffer if you lose a great or top notch player to be replaced by an average level guy. But, the whole team can suffer significantly more if they are not game ready because of a lack of signifiant contact in practice. There is the old truism: You play like you practice! I believe many / most coaches believe this to be the case. I you never practice playing tackle football, you will not be as ready to play your best. We don't benefit from practicing 'touch' or flag football and then suddenly on Saturday afternoons a dozen or so times a year, go out and play rough and tumble full contact agressive football. Osborne had more talent and players (I think we can all at least agree that this is a true statement) so maybe he could risk the injuries but still he practiced 'hard'. His best teams scrimmaged alot - several times a week and often used major scrimmages to really separate the men from the boys. I hope Riley has not become injury paranoid (I felt Frank and subsequent coaches let their fear consume them).
I'm sorry but this isn't the 90s. While I came into coaching thinking it had to be hard all the time. That is just ridiculous now. Unrealistic. Especially in the spring. Going full contact in the spring is NOT going to make you more ready for fall. Especially for only 15 practices.
Football is not about knock out hits. While that's exciting, it's about getting ball carriers to the ground however you can get them there.
I completely disagree with this old mentality. You can't train tough. Not at this age. They should have it already. If they dont. That's on the parents for letting them be soft.
I have two sets of nieces and the ones my brother have raised are tough. They fall down and get up right away and laugh it off. The ones my sister raised are soft because they were picked up and consoled everytime they hurt an eyelash.
Prime example of a 2ND grade kid unrelated to me is a student I watched in PE once. He fell, hit his knee, and started crying. I watched the PE teacher say "get up! Your team needs you." The kids faucet turned off and scored a goal almost immediately.
You train em to be tough at a young age. Not when they are already 18-22 years old