I think a lot depends on timing...one great example of icing the kicker was the Denver Broncos game against Oakland. Janikowski is all ready to kick the game winner (something like a high-40 to low-50 yard kick) ball is snapped and kick is good for the Oakland win....However, Denver called a timeout just before the snap. Next kick goes off the upright and Broncos win in overtime.
Maybe that is just pure luck and nothing to do with a timeout but in some scenarios it does seem it to work.
Maybe that is just pure luck and nothing to do with a timeout but in some scenarios it does seem it to work.