I think people really need to take into account how the playoffs have changed things. Guys like Patterson or Briles would have jumped in the past, because the pool of who can realistically make the BCS champ game was very very small. The by going to 4 (and probably 8 soon) simply being able to win your conference may be enough to play for it all.
So the effect is that if a guy at a P5 school that wants to compete, can compete. This shifts new hires for open jobs to G5 head coaches, hot coordinators, or good HC's at P5 schools who choose not to compete. Or the odd guy who is out of a job for one reason or another.
Of the names listed in this poll, McElwain was the hot G5 coach, who got scooped up by Florida.
Tressel had stated in the past when he took the job he has now, that he is done with coaching.
Schiano? Really? His career record and path are very similar to Riley, but with a personality much closer to Pelini.
Briles, Patterson and Bielima meet that category of schools want to compete. And they are competing, why start over?
Wittingham is interesting, but other than being younger, I don't know as he has any advantages over who we did hire.
And Frost was never, ever, ever going to happen. And really, all the moaning over the years over this not being a training wheels program, people really want to go that route again?
I was underwhelmed when I first saw the hire. But the more I read on Riley, and who else was out there, I think we did get a very good fit. And make no mistake 'fit' is more important that anything else. Ask RichRod about 'fit' he gets 'COTY' at the stops before and after Mich. And really getting into it I think the number one reason people are upset at this point is they had mentally geared up for a 'big name' and then didn't get it. But from what you read Riley has the list of qualities that the fanbase as a whole has been calling for in a coach for years. Character guy, good evaluator of talent, good at coaching his guys up, and even a solid recruiter.
Time will tell, but Riley looks like a very good fit, and probably the best we were going to do this year.