Johnny Rodgers #23

Mike Rozier & Tommie Frazier
Unless I didn't hear it right, I think only Heisman players are going to be on their list. Rozier might make it, but no way Tommie will because he doesn't even qualify. From what I gathered, they are simply ranking the top 25 players who won the Heisman.

I found it quite odd that Johnny Rogers beat out Reggie Bush. While Bush was getting selected into the draft, Rogers was wearing stripes and chains. I would think if you're going to rank the top 25 Heisman winners ever that there should be some bearing as to how they performed after college. I'm hopeful Rozier makes top 15. I wouldn't be surprised if Crouch is even on the list.

What they did after college should have no bearing this is a list of the best COLLEGE players. I don't think it's just heisman winners otherwise I would hope Johnny Rogers would be higher. The fact that the Heisman doesn't go to defensive players or linemen would exclude to many great players.

 
B)-->

QUOTE(Husker B @ Sep 29 2007, 06:33 PM) 227291[/snapback]
ESPN or some one lol is doing top 25 college football players of all-time.

Johnny was listed as #23 this week.
I would rate him a little higher but not top ten. Will be funny if they rate someone that wasn't the best player of the years they played in the top 10.
Bo Jackson and a Miami QB are guaranteed to be in the top 10



I'm still trying to think what Miami QB would be in the top 10 of all time. I can't believe Jim Kelley would be in the top 10 and no way Gino T.

 
Tommie was pretty much what all country was trying to copy...... a mobile qb.

Vince Young was just learning when Tommie was doing his stuff. I would bet that Tommie would out play Vince young...hands down. And I would love to see it.

 
Mike Rozier & Tommie Frazier
Unless I didn't hear it right, I think only Heisman players are going to be on their list. Rozier might make it, but no way Tommie will because he doesn't even qualify. From what I gathered, they are simply ranking the top 25 players who won the Heisman.

I found it quite odd that Johnny Rogers beat out Reggie Bush. While Bush was getting selected into the draft, Rogers was wearing stripes and chains. I would think if you're going to rank the top 25 Heisman winners ever that there should be some bearing as to how they performed after college. I'm hopeful Rozier makes top 15. I wouldn't be surprised if Crouch is even on the list.
That has nothing to do with how good of a college plater they were. Nothing. Has no bearing on this arguement.

Frazier should be in the top 5. Even ESPN can't deny his greatness. Crouch may make it and Rozier should make it.

I think you completely missed the point. Tommie Frazier cannot be on the list. From what I've heard about their rankings, they are only ranking players who actually won the Heisman. TF never won the Heisman. You can say he belongs top 5 all you want, but in this ranking he doesn't qualify because he never and I stress NEVER won the Heisman which is pretty much the only requirement for this ranking.

ESPN may not be able to deny his greatness, but the Heisman voters sure did. He finished 2nd, not 1st in the Heisman voting. He will not be in the top 25 because they're only ranking those individuals that won the Heisman!

 
Didnt Doug Flutie play 4 Miami? I could be way wrong on this of course

Edit: NVM, he played 4 Boston College

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top