Taylor was great, but I am still not convinced that he actually ever "read" anyone on the zone read play. I saw too many times where he made the incorrect read that I think he determined before the snap whether he was keeping/giving the ball.
Taylor would have gone down as one of the greats if he stayed healthy.... Easily one of the most dynamic QB runners i have ever seen. His ability with the option read was so impressive.
I agree to a point, but he still had major success with it. He kept it most of the time, but was good enough to make it work even when he made the wrong choice.
I'm not sure I really buy that he misread it all that often. I'm sure there were times but if you really misread it, you'd have the unblocked defender right in your face. And Martinez's specialty was NOT his ability to juke people and make them miss.
It's certainly easy for us Nebraska fans to nitpick on his reads when we can recite certain plays where he made the wrong read. However, the majority of the time, he did. I would agree with the assessment that he made wrong reads if we had a lot of negative running plays. But we didn't. The option was actually very effective for us. I mean, I can go back to plays from Tommie's, Frost's, and Crouch's days that I can say "he should/shouldn't have pitched it there."
I would have loved to see what TM would have done if he stayed healthy in 2013. He was riding a pretty strong wave from 2012 when he shared first team Big Ten with Braxton Miller. I also would have been curious to see what he would have done with the Eagles. I mean, they could have used some experience running the option. I could have seen him playing a similar role that Brad Smith played with his prospective teams. I similar role they might have in mind for Tim Tebow.