NFL like challenging in College Football next year

That's the one thing I did like as far as NFL vs NCAA replay.

One difference I don't like-- hopefully the NCAA refs won't manage to screw up the system as bad as NFL refs do.

sometimes it seems like there's a conspiracy amond some NFL refs to deliberately make the wrong replay call in order to draw controversy around the whole system. Either that or they really are blind.

it did seem to be a little better last year though.

 
I think it's a good thing.

The coach still has to decide if the challenge is worth risking a timeou, which can be huge.

hopefully the NCAA refs won't manage to screw up the system as bad as NFL refs do.sometimes it seems like there's a conspiracy amond some NFL refs to deliberately make the wrong replay call in order to draw controversy around the whole system. Either that or they really are blind.
Click to expand...
That or it's much easier to see what actually happened when you are sitting at home looking at 5 different camera angles. While the officials have one view from up to 50 yards away. I guess my point is, I don't think some things are as obvious.
ne_nau.gif


 
I like this idea. Hopefully it will help with some of the "human error" that occurs on the field in certain games. What do you think they would have said about the bowl game this year??? Cannot challenge??

 
Well if there is just booth reviews in the last 2 minutes of the halves like NFL the game woulda ended the exact same, but either way you cant challenge a call. or "no call" on penalties for that matter.

i dont think there is any way to spin it to convince me we should have lost :thumbs

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oh, ya i get what you are saying. No they could not have reviewed the offsetting penalty at the end, but they could have reviewed to see if they were all backward passes, etc.

 
I think this system will help the NCAA greatly.....now people can complain about this on top of the terrible calls!!!! :sarcasm :wacko:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top