I totally agree carlfense!!! Please do NOT under any circumstances give Paulus a scholly!! Reasons are the following:
1. Numbers crunch with schollies. We are limited enough as is and this would be a huge waste. With question marks in the interior of the D-line, secondary, and wide receiver, we should hit these areas somewhat hard.
2. As said, barring massive injury rashes he would never take a snap.
3. Have you seen video of this guy throwing? He sucks. Watch the Army All American practice videos sometime, you'll see what I mean.
4. Big XII football is a whole different monster than playing Bball for the last four years. The most contact this guy has had at Duke were the five or six posters of opponents "tea-baggin" while dunking on him in games. Again check out the videos they are quite humorous.
5. I'd rather have one of our young pup QB's taking the reps of being a backup to gain that valuable experience and getting used to that "college game speed." This would be so much more beneficial to the program down the line.
I honestly can't believe that we were this open to Paulus. Huge mistake if he is here in the fall with a scholly and the primary backup.
PS 6. Duke royally sucks the big one!!!!
:rant
I agree with all but point one. The schollie doesn't count for this year's recruiting class. Still I'd rather see it go to a walk on or a transfer (like Marve) that could provide future depth. As much as Would like to see LTW and Green redshirt the year,
I'd far rather see a shirt burned than a schollie that could be used to help build this program.
He isn't coming so the point is moot, but I don't get this comment. You already admit that it doesn't hurt recruiting, but giving out a scholly hurts the building of the program? In what way do you see this? Didn't everyone on here laud Bo for RS almost the entire class of 2008, does all of that talk of building quality depth and building the program not apply here? What is more beneficial to this program then RSing two possible starters or major contributors at QB (Green and Washington)? That is the most important position on the field and getting to RS those players only ensures that this program will have quality depth and talent for longer. I get that giving a scholly to Henery or someone would be nice, but frankly the staff has an obligation to do what is best for the team. Henery isn't going away, he will be there. If the staff feels that it is vital to the future success of the program to ensure that Green and Washington get a RS, then that is what they should do and if adding a transfer from outside is the way to do it, then so be it.