Pessimist Perspective
- Thread starter BIG ERN
- Start date
84HuskerLaw
All-Conference
Field goals are optional usually while punts are mostly mandatory. Not weird at all. Most freshmen are pretty accurate place kickers. Most punters start as freshmen very shaky. Field goal kickers have their heads down and hardly even see the play or opposing players before their done kicking. Punters have to field a long snap that can be wet, cold, wind blown, way off target, etc and then deal with on rushers. Most field goal kicks are gone before the rush gets past the line of scrimmage. Bad snaps are not the kickers responsibility nor do the kickers typically have to concern themselves with having to run or attempt to throw in event of a bad snap, etc.
wiuhusker
Starter
Wasn't trying to say he needed an excuse to go for it on 4th down. Obviously he's and aggressive minded coach. But when you could potentially take 3 points in a close game he may opt to go for it knowing he has a freshman kicker. Or he could go for it because that's just how he coaches.
84HuskerLaw
All-Conference
If Frost likes to go for two instead of a PAT kick for one, then it makes sense he'd be more inclined to go on 4 down for the first down instead of attempt a long field goal for just 3. Punting inside the 5 yard line can be more valuable in some games than even making a field goal kick for beyond 40 yards. Long field kicks are risky as they tend to get blocked or even returned in a real long try and field position is usally lost in missed ones or even made ones as opposed to putting the oppoent backed up to the goal line.
8 points with a TD and 2 pt conversion, sounds pretty good if you do that about 65% of the time. If you have an average yardage gain per offensive snap of say 5 yards, your odds of getting 3 for the points after play, why not go for it. Frost's offense lends itself in my view to a pretty above average PAT success rate with it's ability to spread the defense and make them defend sideline to sideline and the entire end zone. A QB who can 'ad lib' and make something out of nothing can improve your odds of making the 2 or converting that 4 down try. Scoring say, an average of 7.25 points per touhdown instead of 7.0 seems to make sense. I think statistics would say, on average, teams successfully make a PAT kick about 95% which means a TD is actually worth about 9.95 pts. If you are a well above average offense, you should be the average of all teams on the 2 point try. Why not go for. If the oppoent jumps off sides or commits any penalty, you get half the distance, making the odds of a QB sneak go up to probably 80%.
My high school team never had a real good place kicker so we probably went for 2 - 80% of the time and maybe successfully coverted 1/2. We were probably a below average offense.
Field goals were all but never tried except in do or die, last second cases to win or tie from beyond the 15 yard line. Frost believes his offense is way above average so he wants TDs not field goals.
8 points with a TD and 2 pt conversion, sounds pretty good if you do that about 65% of the time. If you have an average yardage gain per offensive snap of say 5 yards, your odds of getting 3 for the points after play, why not go for it. Frost's offense lends itself in my view to a pretty above average PAT success rate with it's ability to spread the defense and make them defend sideline to sideline and the entire end zone. A QB who can 'ad lib' and make something out of nothing can improve your odds of making the 2 or converting that 4 down try. Scoring say, an average of 7.25 points per touhdown instead of 7.0 seems to make sense. I think statistics would say, on average, teams successfully make a PAT kick about 95% which means a TD is actually worth about 9.95 pts. If you are a well above average offense, you should be the average of all teams on the 2 point try. Why not go for. If the oppoent jumps off sides or commits any penalty, you get half the distance, making the odds of a QB sneak go up to probably 80%.
My high school team never had a real good place kicker so we probably went for 2 - 80% of the time and maybe successfully coverted 1/2. We were probably a below average offense.
Field goals were all but never tried except in do or die, last second cases to win or tie from beyond the 15 yard line. Frost believes his offense is way above average so he wants TDs not field goals.
The only WR of the top two in the depth chart that may not be a speed guy would be Reimers — not sure how fast he is. I wonder if Walters will want to place him at TE some. But he is a big target regardless whether he is at WR or TE.
Dansker
Starter
Reimers could be a Todd Peterson guy. Solid hands, effective route runner. I'll gladly take that. As for TE, I think Stoll and Allen will be good. Stoll runs with a purpose like a full back. I like Allen's acceleration.
Dansker
Starter
Stanley isn't exactly a burner either. Might be why he and Reimers are in the same spot on the depth chart.
Xmas32
All-Conference
I've thought about this a bit as well and it'll be interesting to see how this shakes out. On the positive side, NU has absolute giants at the TE spot with Stoll being the shortest at *only* 6'4 and I'm confident NU can create some mismatches in the RZ with those dudes.
My pessimistic view stems more from other teams we are playing than what Nebraska brings to the table. I believe the team will be night and day better from last year in terms of playing with passion and aggression. I think they will be much better coached. I think the talent on the team will finally shine through as many spots.
We have a tough schedule and there is no getting around that. We will be better, but I don't know if it is enough to get us past 7 wins. Watching the Purdue/Northwestern game, made me have doubt. They were both better than I thought they would be. Not perfect by any means, but they both played solid sound aggressive football. That type of play can take you far.
That is all
We have a tough schedule and there is no getting around that. We will be better, but I don't know if it is enough to get us past 7 wins. Watching the Purdue/Northwestern game, made me have doubt. They were both better than I thought they would be. Not perfect by any means, but they both played solid sound aggressive football. That type of play can take you far.
That is all
Last edited by a moderator:
The Big Ten West will be fun the next few years. We just need to keep recruiting well and we will be fine. Frost got a huge compliment last week that went unnoticed, and it was from Josh Heupel. Couldn't stop raving about how good the culture was down there, and how efficient the players practiced and how it was them helping him get everything set up. When you can leave a program and your teachings remain, that's high praise. So, we know he can do it, and if these other programs keep up then more power to them.
Oh, no I think the future looks very bright. I am just specifically talking about this year. It will be a meat grinder of a year. It will be fun but I just don't know what will happen. I don't think we will know after Akron either. I think they will crush them on adrenaline alone.
When it comes to the Big Ten West I'm not as worried about this year as I am the future, because we know teams like Purdue are still being held back by QB play. All three teams last night showed me that's their bottleneck. Until that position changes, I'm not that concerned.
I thought Clayton Thorson played just fine last night. The #4 for Purdue is going to be really good. I was impressed with the defenses being hard nosed. Not that super athletic, but tough. I hope Nebraska can show a superior athlete that will, along with toughness and aggressiveness will hold the day against teams like Purdue/NW and Iowa.
Nebraska has been out toughed and has shown very little resiliency for a long time. Not just with Riley, but with Pelini's last 2-3 teams. NW and Iowa are never going to out recruit Nebraska, but they sure have been a tougher team than Nebraska. You could probably throw Michigan St into that group also.
I guess that is what I want to see out of this team more than anything. I want to see no quit.