EbylHusker
Banned
Are you mad about the refs making the correct call according the rules, or how the rules have been set?
Replay officials
- Thread starter holvy83
- Start date
Vince from ShamWOW
All-Conference
I'm upset they blew the call. He had complete control of the ball while in bounds. The ground cannot cause a fumble of incompletion.
Are you one of the refs that missed the call or a family of one of them?
EbylHusker
Banned
Nope, but I'm a person who went and looked at the NCAA rulebook for the 2009-2010 football season. It clearly states that it is an incomplete pass if the receiver does not maintain possession through contact with the ground. I can link you to it if you like?
Vince from ShamWOW
All-Conference
EbylHusker
Banned
As I thought, you have no interest in what the actual rules from the NCAA state. You just want to whine about a call you don't understand. Congrats.
knapplc
International Man of Mystery
holvy83
Starter
Rules or not, when the play happened, I would hope everyone in Huskerland saw that as a completion and a touchdown and when it was called incomplete most of us went into kicking the dog mode and not grab the NCAA rule book mode. Since I was pretty much :wasted after the game and did not find the time to jump on this board I did not realize a thread was already discussed when I jumped on this morning, that is why i started the thread the way I did.
REDSTEEL
All-Conference
Years ago that same catch was a touch down but with todays rules it is an incomplete pass. <_<
What I wonder is why after years and years of hearing how the ground cannot cause a fumble they decided that needed to be amended. Course pretty soon if you look at the QB weird it will be 15 yard penalty the way things are going. chuckleshuffle
What I wonder is why after years and years of hearing how the ground cannot cause a fumble they decided that needed to be amended. Course pretty soon if you look at the QB weird it will be 15 yard penalty the way things are going. chuckleshuffle
Last edited by a moderator: