It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Kinda playing devil's advocate...It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Nice post. Per your bolded part Nebraska doesn't have the personnel to line up and let Martinez or whoever is back there just run. The secret is out. If we had a smash mouth, monster offensive line that might work. There has to be some variation there.Kinda playing devil's advocate...It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
I know it's not '83, '94, or '97, but here's the thing, the defenses may be more impressive now, than back then. Would have the aforemention great Husker QB's have thrived against the defenses now, with the offensive and defensive scheme's being implemented?
Everyone's forgetting we're trying to base an entire body of work off of one year.
If you really want to see what this kid has got, you've got have him start, hopefully play an entire season injury free. Not until then, you will truly find out, if he's got what it takes, or he was a shot in the dark, where people will talk about him years from now, about what could have been. His lack of decisiveness has been pontificated upon ad nauseum, which will have to change, or it'll be over early.
I don't think anyone would be opposed to a running QB. Everyone is opposed to a running QB that is more of a detriment. We've had several great running QB's and it's shown that under the right system, a running QB can be another viable option.
Tenopir said college football trends have changed since Nebraska last powered its way a national championship.
"Very, very few teams are going to line up in a two-back (offense) and hammer the football," he said.
Mark me down as a TMart fan.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Tommie Frazier looked bad against Iowa State his freshman year, a game Nebraska lost, and Frazier wasn't even hurt.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
You're comparing Nebraska's REDSHIRT freshman quarterback to past Husker legends and now you are comparing our offense to Auburn and Oregon's.Tommie Frazier looked bad against Iowa State his freshman year, a game Nebraska lost, and Frazier wasn't even hurt.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Eric Crouch struggled throughout his freshman year, and his team finished the year with fewer wins than Martinez's 2010 squad.
As for Steve Taylor and Turner Gill, their only playing time their freshman season was with the freshman team, not with the varsity.
Scott Frost was at Stanford his freshman year, struggling to learn the west coast offense before transferring to Nebraska.
Taylor Martinez's freshman year > any other freshman QB ever to play at Nebraska. The only guy who comes close is Frazier, and he wasn't playing hurt for half the season.
It doesn't matter what year it is. Option offenses work. If they didn't, Auburn and Oregon wouldn't have been playing for the national championship the other night. Martinez is an option QB. Nebraska's is an option offense.
If you want to go back to the west coast offense, that's fine. But the west coast offense was introduced to Nebraska this last decade, and that was our worst decade since the 1950's. I'd rather move forward with a modern offense, but one that reflects the philosophies that allowed Nebraska to be great in the first place.
Yea I dont get these threads comparing to happened this year to what happened in 90's is just freaking stupid. College Football world as changed so much since then you cant even really compare. With the 85 scholy limit, more freshman are asked to come in and play alot right away. So comparing TMart to TF is ridiculous. Plus I dont think TF started playing till about the 3rd or 4th game that season, also I believe 2 games less were played in 93 season.You're comparing Nebraska's REDSHIRT freshman quarterback to past Husker legends and now you are comparing our offense to Auburn and Oregon's.Tommie Frazier looked bad against Iowa State his freshman year, a game Nebraska lost, and Frazier wasn't even hurt.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Eric Crouch struggled throughout his freshman year, and his team finished the year with fewer wins than Martinez's 2010 squad.
As for Steve Taylor and Turner Gill, their only playing time their freshman season was with the freshman team, not with the varsity.
Scott Frost was at Stanford his freshman year, struggling to learn the west coast offense before transferring to Nebraska.
Taylor Martinez's freshman year > any other freshman QB ever to play at Nebraska. The only guy who comes close is Frazier, and he wasn't playing hurt for half the season.
It doesn't matter what year it is. Option offenses work. If they didn't, Auburn and Oregon wouldn't have been playing for the national championship the other night. Martinez is an option QB. Nebraska's is an option offense.
If you want to go back to the west coast offense, that's fine. But the west coast offense was introduced to Nebraska this last decade, and that was our worst decade since the 1950's. I'd rather move forward with a modern offense, but one that reflects the philosophies that allowed Nebraska to be great in the first place.
Whatever works for you man.
We shall definitely see next year won't we...
Auburn and Oregon run variations of spread option offenses. That's what Nebraska has been moving towards. It's a legit comparison. I'm completely aware we're not as good at it yet, but people on this board are arguing for a move away from that scheme. I'm arguing for a move to get better at that scheme.You're comparing Nebraska's REDSHIRT freshman quarterback to past Husker legends and now you are comparing our offense to Auburn and Oregon's.Tommie Frazier looked bad against Iowa State his freshman year, a game Nebraska lost, and Frazier wasn't even hurt.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Eric Crouch struggled throughout his freshman year, and his team finished the year with fewer wins than Martinez's 2010 squad.
As for Steve Taylor and Turner Gill, their only playing time their freshman season was with the freshman team, not with the varsity.
Scott Frost was at Stanford his freshman year, struggling to learn the west coast offense before transferring to Nebraska.
Taylor Martinez's freshman year > any other freshman QB ever to play at Nebraska. The only guy who comes close is Frazier, and he wasn't playing hurt for half the season.
It doesn't matter what year it is. Option offenses work. If they didn't, Auburn and Oregon wouldn't have been playing for the national championship the other night. Martinez is an option QB. Nebraska's is an option offense.
If you want to go back to the west coast offense, that's fine. But the west coast offense was introduced to Nebraska this last decade, and that was our worst decade since the 1950's. I'd rather move forward with a modern offense, but one that reflects the philosophies that allowed Nebraska to be great in the first place.
Whatever works for you man.
We shall definitely see next year won't we...
Auburn and Oregon run variations of spread option offenses. That's what Nebraska has been moving towards. It's a legit comparison. I'm completely aware we're not as good at it yet, but people on this board are arguing for a move away from that scheme. I'm arguing for a move to get better at that scheme.You're comparing Nebraska's REDSHIRT freshman quarterback to past Husker legends and now you are comparing our offense to Auburn and Oregon's.Tommie Frazier looked bad against Iowa State his freshman year, a game Nebraska lost, and Frazier wasn't even hurt.It's simple. This isn't 1983, 1994 or 1997 that's why. You're obviously obsessed with Martinez's gaudy rushing numbers early on.Hercules said:I fail to comprehend why someone who lived through the glory days of the program would be opposed to a running QB like Taylor Martinez. We are the winningest football program in the last 40 years thanks in part to QBs who were very similar to Taylor Martinez. And out of all of those QBs - including Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Jammal Lord, Scott Frost, Brook Berringer - Taylor had BY FAR the best freshman season. It's not even close, Taylor's freshman year dwarfed Tommie Frazier's freshman year, and Eric Crouch's freshman year, and I don't think anybody else even got playing time their freshman year.
Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch, Scott Frost and Brook Berringer. None of those guys got towards the end of the season and still looked as lost as Martinez did behind the pocket in the Big 12 Championship game loss and the embarrassing bowl loss.
I could care less about the gaudy rushing numbers TMart put up earlier this year. Obviously some people here are blinded by them...
It's great that he ran all over the Western Kentucky's, Idaho's and Kansas State's of the world but until he win's as many games as Turner Gill, Steve Taylor, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch and Scott Frost don't start comparing the two. Thanks.
Eric Crouch struggled throughout his freshman year, and his team finished the year with fewer wins than Martinez's 2010 squad.
As for Steve Taylor and Turner Gill, their only playing time their freshman season was with the freshman team, not with the varsity.
Scott Frost was at Stanford his freshman year, struggling to learn the west coast offense before transferring to Nebraska.
Taylor Martinez's freshman year > any other freshman QB ever to play at Nebraska. The only guy who comes close is Frazier, and he wasn't playing hurt for half the season.
It doesn't matter what year it is. Option offenses work. If they didn't, Auburn and Oregon wouldn't have been playing for the national championship the other night. Martinez is an option QB. Nebraska's is an option offense.
If you want to go back to the west coast offense, that's fine. But the west coast offense was introduced to Nebraska this last decade, and that was our worst decade since the 1950's. I'd rather move forward with a modern offense, but one that reflects the philosophies that allowed Nebraska to be great in the first place.
Whatever works for you man.
We shall definitely see next year won't we...
And I'm not comparing Martinez's freshman year to Husker legends' senior years. I'm comparing his freshman year to THEIR freshman year, and saying, "Damn, he had a better freshman year than any of those guys. Maybe we should stop dumping on him for a second."
And Huskerscott, when you say that defenses will "figure out how to stop the zone read if they haven't already..." Defenses figured out in the 80's how to stop the triple option - that doesn't mean they could execute and do it. Teams right now know how to stop the zone read option - but again, that doesn't mean they can execute and do it. The zone read option isn't a gimmick, it's as legit of a concept as the old triple option, and those things are never going to go away in college football. They're always going to stress defenses, they're never going to be obsolete.