While I understand that there is a pride factor in claiming NU for both schools... a trophy rivalry, seriously?
Iowa's a border state and they have an over inflated sense of greatness, so it will be fun holding onto the somewhat lame but good intentioned attempt at a trophy for years at a time.
You just decribed Missouri, Kansas State and Colorado.
Iowa State and Kansas are border states but generally know their status in college football.
We had a trophy with Missouri.. that hardly anyone knew it existed. Guess we should have created meaningless trophies with Kansas State and Colorado too just to hold onto them for years at a time.
Trophies are dumb unless they have a reason to exist. There is no reason for a trophy with Iowa. There's a slight reason for one with Northwestern but no-one would care. There's a reason for one with Michigan and Penn State based on real history, but those also need to develop further.
Creating these "rivalries" and "Trophy Games" out of nothing just for the sake of having them is very, very lame.