Can we stop pretending like our roster was left in good shape and that there was no recovery that had to take place? A part of that blame also lies on the current staff and their handling of roster management last year (especially on the DL and at WR).
HCMR from the best I can see is playing the long game. We're not burning redshirts to patch holes (e.g. POB), he's trying to get everything stacked up so that we're not scrambling to have a team. That is going to mean taking a few lumps here and there to get players a RS. Luckily our recruiting at WR seems good enough that we'll have tFR come in and be able to play well. This is going to look less pretty where strength and conditioning come up the most. DE is still going to burn us, we have Freedom, we have some good DTs, but I think we'll be a liability at one end.
Depending on the health of our OL and our development, it's going to be feast or famine. If Lee is as good as we want to pretend him to be, or if POB has some serious development, this will be a fun team depending on the line play. Remember that game Fyfe started, the offense was multiple and we used all our tools. Fyfe was the backup for a reason. He had his issues, if we get improved accuracy and touch at the QB position, we will be fine with a pocket guy. If Tre plays well, Oz heals up and gets out of the doghouse, and Wilbon continues to develop, we will be fine (sorry Taylor) with the run. That said, we're going to be thin at the line for about 2 more years IMO. The depth wasn't there, we've got some great potential, but we need it to pan out, and we need more potential behind it.
What I want to see in 2017 is a few things.
Hold the course: we safe movement in the right direction. The benchmark is set for 2017, it perhaps dips a bit in 2018. Next year is still going to be rough. Oregon recruits ballers, Wisconsin, tOSU, and Penn State are all going to continue to be good teams. Iowa is going to continue to be Iowa. We should be competitive though and I think we pull off another 9-10 wins.
I want us to continue to build depth and show promise. All those high potential guys need to start delivering a little bit or showing it in 2017 (Lightbourn, Dismuke, Lamar Jackson, the 2016 OL recruits, and one DE I'm guessing Alex Davis though Daishon should be close as well). I think we are fine at LB and in our Secondary. Everything else I'm a little more shaky on.
Finally I want the team to stay disciplined. Fewer penalties, no going on tilt after rough starts to games, being consistent. This years team was still anything but consistent. I think so much of that was on TA. When he was good the team could get going, but when he was bad it put way too much pressure on the D. The D showed huge resiliency, but our DL was a bit of a miracle with how they played. My memory is the board last year right after the draft declarations knew that. I think they benefited from an improved secondary, but it's something that teams could game plan against and with the right athletes at the right positions (OSU all over the place, Iowa in the trenches) could hugely take advantage of. A consistent offense that doesn't get as many 3 and outs improves every aspect of the team. It means less punting from bad field position, and it means a better rested D that imo is still going to struggle against teams with great/elite line play.
The wins will come eventually. We need a solid foundation to work from first though. IMO this staff is working to give that foundation through recruiting and culture change. I think that takes time.