I think a team's performance in one away game falls far behind a number of things when it comes to what is important to them during recruiting. It would actually be an interesting question to ask a Senior. For me it would be (not necessarily in this order):
- Coaches
- Position coach
- Facilities
- Support (academic and after football)
- Current roster at position
- Team potential for 2-3 years out.
- Location.
If I see a team that has strong coaching, facilities etc, and I'm as confident in my skills as these guys are, I actually look at the spot where I think I can get on the field faster, where I can be the guy that helps turn around a program (vs. the one that joins one on the downturn), where I can make the most out of my skills to get into the NFL or where I can get the best degree to use after FB. As long as it's not a losing record program I don't give a hoot what the numbers are. Now if the team was getting beat by 6-7 teams a year, or if they're losing big time to programs like Miami of Ohio or Baylor then I'd be worried. Playing a top school tough at their home stadium wouldn't make me bat an eye.