druski_2k5
Five-Star Recruit
Oh I could understand why he would want to sit certain players. Pressure, adjustments, learning, technique, etc. I understand all of that. And thanks for clearing that up, if all schools aren't held to it then it would be not wise for us to do it as it would hurt recruiting a ton. Good point there. Makes more sense now.Bo's position isn't necessarily contradictory, and it mirrors what most coaches think. Most coaches want to redshirt freshman for a variety of reasons - get them acclimated to being away from home, get them used to college classes and time-management, get them used to the speed of the game, etc., all without the added pressure of having to perform. Yes, some of them can help - but coaches would still rather give them a year in the weight room and the classroom.So let me get this straight: Bo wants to make Freshman ineligible to play, for various reasons, yet these same Freshman are expected to make in impact for our team? It just seems like saying two things at once. "These guys shouldn't be on the field, however, we are excited about X, Y and Z contributing in their true Freshman year."
So which one is it?
If they can make an impact we play them but if they can't we red-shirt or sit them?
Isn't that the benefit of red-shirting by getting adjusted into what they have to do? Why make them ineligible when we can just red-shirt them?
However, given that a lot of kids state that "early playing time" is a factor in recruiting, coupled with the fact that kids are eligible as freshman - well, a coach pretty much has to play those that can. And since they are eligible, you play those that will help. But coaches really would like the rule - so long as all schools are held to it and can't use it as a recruiting point ("We play freshmen at State U - but Nebraska doesn't...").
I was always under the impression if a player could contribute, then he would play. As well as if a player "needed" to work on some things, or get his adjustment period down, and worry about all of that first year stuff, then we would red-shirt him. Or if there was so much depth he wouldn't see playing time and would red-shirt.
Makes a little more sense in recruiting and keeping things fair for all schools if there was such a rule. I've heard Bo mention it a few times but I haven't heard it talked about much on a national level.