Last cycle, Florida State courted similarly established transfers, too. But when they failed to sign top targets like
Kyle Kennard (a Nagurski Trophy finalist at South Carolina),
Nic Scourton (one of the SEC’s most disruptive defensive linemen for Texas A&M) and
Carter Smith (Indiana’s starting left tackle), the Seminoles had to pivot to the portal’s next tier. They veered further from production and more toward potential.
Six of their 17 transfers were coveted, top-110 national recruits in high school who signed with major programs (Georgia, Alabama) but totaled just four career collegiate starts. Another, receiver
Malik Benson, was the nation’s top junior college recruit in 2023 but caught only one touchdown in his 14 games for Alabama.
If Seminoles staffers thought they could fix the talented prospects they unsuccessfully recruited previously, they were wrong.
Bama’s backups, it turns out, were backups for a reason; the front office, a former staffer said, “went 1-for-17.”
“They completely failed,” said a source familiar with the team’s roster construction.