2013 NFL Discussion Thread

tschu said:
If you don't think Peyton is GOAT you're horribly misguided
Click to expand...
GOAT is nothing but an opinion, unless you're talking about basketball
default_wink.png


Just because someone doesn't agree with you doesn't mean they're horribly misguided.

 
Lots of guys could throw the ball. Peyton is a surgeon. He's dissecting defenses with his mind and a noodle arm and a fused neck at age 37. And just had the best season in NFL history.

 
tschu said:
Lots of guys could throw the ball. Peyton is a surgeon. He's dissecting defenses with his mind and a noodle arm and a fused neck at age 37. And just had the best season in NFL history.
Click to expand...
If he wins the super bowl, it will be the greatest season by a QB in NFL history. If he doesn't, well... It won't be.

 
For what its worth:

Per Game Averages

Manning- 270 yds 2 td 0.9 int 65.5% (1 Super Bowl)

Brady- 257 yds 1.88 td 0.7 int 63.4 % (3 Super Bowls)

Manning played the majority of his career with the likes of Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dwight Clark, and now Thomas/Decker/Welker/Thomas. Brady played the majority of his career with Troy Brown, Deion Branch, Reche Caldwell, David Givens, with brief stints of Moss/Welker/Hernandez/Gronkowiski.

Everyone's entitled to their opinion.

 
Hint: if you want to compare a QB with Manning, it better be Montana or Marino (or Unitas if you really wanna go throwback). Get that Brady crap out of here, if Peyton played for Belichick with that defense he'd have 6 Super Bowls. Brady probably isn't even top-5, although he's close.

 
tschu said:
Hint: if you want to compare a QB with Manning, it better be Montana or Marino (or Unitas if you really wanna go throwback). Get that Brady crap out of here, if Peyton played for Belichick with that defense he'd have 6 Super Bowls. Brady probably isn't even top-5, although he's close.
Click to expand...
You have nothing to back that up. It's just your opinion.

 
Not only is every stat in Peyton's favor (NY/A, ANY/A, TD%, INT%, etc) but Brady had the benefit of some ridiculous defenses and Bill Belichick. Meanwhile Peyton had to stumble through seasons with lolMora, Dungy (most overrated coach of all time) and LOLOLOLJimCaldwell.

Peyton on the Pats wins 6 Super Bowls.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top