Sorry to offend you DaveH...but
It's a proven fact that kickers are really hard to evaluate from film...seeing one in person might be different but few staffs will make the trip to evaluate a kicker.
Add the transition of going from 2" to 1" tee, not being able to use a worn out ball of choice etc.....all kickers are a wildcard until proven, regardless of rtheir ankings from a film.
Callahan's decision to not kick the field goal was based on knowing his kickers limitations how can he be faulted for that?