^ yeah (and those were in his best years) - even in those years he was still losing to almost every ranked team he played. Since Grobe has been at WF, he has beaten a total of 6 ranked teams (03' NC State #14, 06' Boston C. #16, 06' G. Tech #22, 07' FSU #21, 08' FSU #25, 11' #22 FSU).
6 ranked teams, and not highly ranked ones at that - over the course of 10 years. It's a different level of football entirely at Nebraska. Grobe has had some downright awful seasons at WF in the last 4-5 years. The fact that he was even a candidate is scary. We'd be on our next coach already if he had been hired. So rather than Pelini going into his 5th year, we'd have someone like Randy Edsall, or All Golden going into their second year. Wonder where Pelini would be?
Might be fun to speculate...
How about this:
2008: NU hires Grobe. Pelini stays at LSU. LSU goes 8-5 (as in reality), but this time the administration does not resist the fans' unrest, knowing Pelini is ready for a HC job. They show Les Miles the door and promote Pelini. Miles ends up replacing Fulmer at Tennesse, making some LSU fans nervous that he stayed in the SEC. Miles was also in consideration for Auburn, Boston College, and Purdue. He wishes he would have taken the Michigan job the year before. Lane Kiffin, fired from the Raiders, never gets a HC job, and the douche is never heard from again, other than being a whiny assistant somewhere. Grobe goes 5-7 with NU, but after being jaded by the Callahan years, there is not a great uproar yet.
2009: Pelini goes 9-4 at LSU. Grobe goes 5-7 again at NU. Osborne, having just hired and invested in a guy he respects, does not want to fire Grobe, but it is clearly not working out. Meanwhile, Turner Gill had been courted by Auburn the year before and was now fielding potential offers from other schools, including Kansas. Osborne decided to pull the trigger, firing Grobe and hiring his good friend Gill.
2010: Gill goes 9-4 in his first year, without having to flip an entire culture as he would have at Kansas, with Zac Lee having a good senior season. He loses to Texas, Okie St, Mizzou, and TAMU but gets a victory over Iowa in the Insight Bowl. Pelini goes 9-4 again with LSU. By virtue of OSU and MU winning over NU in this reality, those two meet in the Big XII Championship game. Ratings suck. Oklahoma's self esteem is even lower, and the Big XII's angst is at an all-time high with NU and CU already on the way out.
With OU hurt, and OSU emboldened, they begin an uprising in the conference and finally stand up to Texas. Texas decides to go independent, TAMU goes to the SEC, Mizzou stays, and the Big XII adds TCU, BYU, and Boise, to begin in 2012.
2011: NU and LSU are both 9-4 again. With LSU not in the National Championship picture, Oklahoma State faces Bama in the NC game (losing, of course). Without the added controversy of the rematch we saw in reality, there is no impetus from the BCS Presidents to entertain any idea of a playoff. The regular BCS format is extended through the year 3000.
Having been emboldened by the football coaching change, Osborne decides to pull the trigger on Doc Sadler as well and hires a top-notch replacement. NU basketball begins to rebuild a year ahead of schedule.
2012: Urban Meyer's return to coaching falls flat, PSU goes into a decline from which it will never recover, and Turner Gill's NU team goes 13-1, losing only in an upset to Michigan State the week after a hard fought comeback win versus Michigan (in a game in which Denard Robinson is hurt, eerily similar to the 2011 Ohio State game). NU is Big Ten champs and beats Oregon in the Rose Bowl. Pelini goes 8-5 with LSU, and their fans start to grumble. The National Championship game features West Virginia, having gone undefeated in a crappy Big East that they never left, losing to Oklahoma.
After the season, Oregon, Alabama, Auburn, and Ohio State are rocked by major recruiting scandals. Ohio State, already on probation, gets the death penalty. Oregon's entire staff is fired in the fallout. Scott Frost returns home to take an assistant job under Turner Gill. With Bama and Auburn now crippled, LSU fans don't feel so bad about Pelini, and he gets an extension.
2013: Nebraska dominates the Big Ten and beats independent Texas for the National Championship. Taylor Martinez wins the Heisman. LSU wins the SEC, but the damaged conference does not produce another NC contender. Nebraska Basketball also wins the Big Ten. Osborne retires for good.
2014: Due to the pervasive corruption in all of college football, except Nebraska of course, and the worsening information about concussions in the sport, the NCAA and majority of schools abruptly cancel all football-related activities at the college level, pending further research and regulations. Nebraska is forever regarded is the last, and best, champion in the annals of college football history.